DC gun rights backfire, judge upholds registration in Heller II - New York News

DC gun rights backfire, judge upholds registration in Heller II

Posted: Updated:
WASHINGTON - D.C.’s gun rights activists had a setback on Thursday when District Court Judge James Boasberg handed down his ruling in the case known as Heller II. The judge upheld the city’s gun registration laws as constitutional.
 
This ruling means that if you want a legal gun at home in D.C., you still have to go through the 12 or so steps it takes to register it.
 
These unique laws started after the Supreme Court ruled in 2008 in the first Heller case that the 30-year ban on handguns violated Second Amendment rights.
 
I talked to City Council Chairman Phil Mendelson, who wrote the gun laws, after the ruling came down. He said he’s “pleased” with outcome. The chairman said that the court upheld that a “minimal amount of burden” on a citizen is acceptable when it comes to constitutional rights because it is balanced by public safety.
 
“I’ve said all along that registration is not about trying to catch those who are law abiding,” explained Mendelson. “It’s about making it easier for police to detain and arrest those who are not law abiding and don’t want the government knowing they have a gun.”
 
Steve Halbrook, the lawyer for Dick Heller in this current case and the other plaintiffs, told me that the ruling was a “great disappointment.”
 
Halbrook pointed out that D.C. claims that “it needs to register guns so police can check if a gun may be present at a crime scene.  It turns out that they don’t do so, obviously because criminals don’t register guns.” He is referring to D.C. Police Chief Cathy Lanier’s testimony in a deposition in Heller II in which she said that her officers do not call in to check for registered guns when responding to a call.
 
Even if they did, police testimony shows that the registered gun database is only kept in the Firearms Registration Section that is only staffed weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
 
So what this ruling means in practical sense is that D.C. residents will still have to abide by the strictest gun laws anywhere in the country in order to have a legal gun in the home.
 
Specifically, residents have to appear in person at police headquarters to be fingerprinted and photographed. They also much pass a written test on the gun laws and take a course on gun safety. They have to bring each gun owned or bought to the police station.
 
The limit on one handgun a month or 12 a year stays intact. Judge Boasberg wrote: “That is more than enough.”
 
The District is also the only place except Hawaii that requires long guns -- shotguns and rifles -- be registered. This is despite the fact that these firearms are rarely used in crimes.
 
Potential gun owners also have to pay fees to register each gun. Then, they have to pay a fee every three years to re-register as a firearms owner. The first time they re-register, they have to go to the police station again to be fingerprinted and photographed.
 
Halbrook said that Heller and the other plaintiffs in this case will appeal the decision.
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Rapper Joe Budden arrested

    Rapper Joe Budden arrested

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 1:52 PM EDT2014-08-27 17:52:27 GMT

    Rapper Joe Budden was arrested by the NYPD on Wednesday in connection with the robbery of his ex-girlfriend's cell phone earlier this month. Police had been looking for the New Jersey resident since Aug. 18 after a heated argument with the woman inside his car in Washington Heights. After he was arrested on Wednesday, Budden apparently Tweeted several times from jail.

    Rapper Joe Budden was arrested by the NYPD on Wednesday in connection with the robbery of his ex-girlfriend's cell phone earlier this month. Police had been looking for the New Jersey resident since Aug. 18 after a heated argument with the woman inside his car in Washington Heights. After he was arrested on Wednesday, Budden apparently Tweeted several times from jail.

  • Soldier who killed herself at Va. Army base was from Yonkers

    Soldier who killed herself at Va. Army base was from Yonkers

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 1:28 PM EDT2014-08-27 17:28:56 GMT

    The Army has identified the soldier who barricaded herself in a building at a Virginia base and then fatally shot herself in the head.  Fort Lee officials on Wednesday say it was 33-year-old Sgt. 1st Class Paula M. Walker of Yonkers

    The Army has identified the soldier who barricaded herself in a building at a Virginia base and then fatally shot herself in the head.  Fort Lee officials on Wednesday say it was 33-year-old Sgt. 1st Class Paula M. Walker of Yonkers

  • Cuomo orders investigation into Time Warner outage

    Cuomo orders investigation into Time Warner outage

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 1:15 PM EDT2014-08-27 17:15:06 GMT
    Time Warner Cable suffered a nationwide outage primarily impacting its Internet service on Wednesday morning. More than 11 million customers were affected.  Several hours later, NY Gov. Andrew Cuomo ordered an investigation into the outage. "I have directed the New York State Department of Public Service to investigate this outage as part of its review of Comcast's proposed merger with Time Warner," said Cuomo.
    Time Warner Cable suffered a nationwide outage primarily impacting its Internet service on Wednesday morning. More than 11 million customers were affected.  Several hours later, NY Gov. Andrew Cuomo ordered an investigation into the outage. "I have directed the New York State Department of Public Service to investigate this outage as part of its review of Comcast's proposed merger with Time Warner," said Cuomo.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices