Sexting case dismissed - New York News

Court: Alleged sexting between teacher, minor is free speech

Posted: Updated:

The case against a junior high school teacher accused of sexting a 13-year-old girl has been dropped, but not for lack of evidence.

It was dropped because courts and prosecutors say the Texas law banning adults from sex chat with minors violates the right to free speech.

An appeals court ruled that a teacher can participate in a certain level of sexting with a student, and it's not against the law.

"They dropped the ball," said defense attorney Jim Shaw. "They dropped the ball."

Shaw says although Texas legislators tried to write a law that would stop sexually explicit texts messages from an adult to a child, they didn't get it right.

"It doesn't sufficiently define the law," said Shaw.

But it worked in favor of his client, 31-year-old Sean Williams, an Everman ISD middle school teacher arrested in 2012 after admitting to sending sexually-related texts to one of his 13-year-old students.

In October 2013, the Tarrant County District Attorney's office dropped the charge of improper relationship between an educator and student.

The reason is because that same month, a Texas appeals court ruled in a similar case that texts between a teacher and a student are protected under the First Amendment.

The texts were considered free speech.

"It's morally wrong," said Shaw. "It's improper; it's gonna be subject to someone being terminated. I guess they could be sued conceivably in a civil action, but as far as it being against the law, at that time, it was not."

According to the arrest warrant affidavit, the texts discussed "if either of them walked around naked in their homes... descriptions of their sexual preferences and fantasies."

The affidavit mentioned pictures that the two sent each other, saying, "The victim wearing a bra and no shirt," and one the suspect sent her "of his chest with no shirt…"

However, Williams claimed the photo was a picture from a fitness magazine.

With the precedent set by the appeals court opinion, and because Williams was never accused of asking to meet the girl somewhere, or asking her to have sex with him, he didn't technically break the law.

"You can talk trash, you can talk disgusting things, but if you're not soliciting someone to meet you or engage in an act, then it's protected by the First Amendment," said Shaw.

The D.A.'s office says now it has to go back and reexamine a handful of cases and, if possible, re-indict them under a different penal code that deals with online solicitation of a minor.

In Williams' case, that wasn't an option.

If the law is changed in the future, the district attorney said that due to too many variables, he couldn't answer whether or not the case, and others like it, could be prosecuted.

There are provisions in the law that say if you pass a new law, you can't go back and prosecute someone for something they did if it wasn't a crime at the time.

Since the case was dismissed, Williams can teach again if someone hired him.

The Texas Education Agency shows Williams' teaching certificate to be valid through 2017.

However, it also shows that it is under review by the TEA.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Friday Night Live: August 22, 2014

    Friday Night Live: August 22, 2014

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:34 PM EDT2014-08-23 02:34:20 GMT
    This is Fox 5's Friday Night Live, a weekly celebration of the end of the work week. All summer long, the Fox 5 team brings you the latest in entertainment, nightlife, food, and music in our area. In this episode: Ace Frehley, Big Sean, Week End Trends, and Chef Luca Manfé of MasterChef.
    This is Fox 5's Friday Night Live, a weekly celebration of the end of the work week. All summer long, the Fox 5 team brings you the latest in entertainment, nightlife, food, and music in our area. In this episode: Ace Frehley, Big Sean, Week End Trends, and Chef Luca Manfé of MasterChef.
  • Berg'n: new beer and food hall in Brooklyn

    Berg'n: new beer and food hall in Brooklyn

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:00 PM EDT2014-08-23 02:00:35 GMT
    The guys behind the Brooklyn Flea and Smorgasburg are at it again with a new food and booze venue called Berg'n, a new beer hall in Crown Heights. The place doesn't officially open until August 27, 2014, but owners Eric Demby and Jonathan Butler are giving it a test run for special guests, family, and the press.
    The guys behind the Brooklyn Flea and Smorgasburg are at it again with a new food and booze venue called Berg'n, a new beer hall in Crown Heights. The place doesn't officially open until August 27, 2014, but owners Eric Demby and Jonathan Butler are giving it a test run for special guests, family, and the press.
  • Giving your college-bound kids their space

    Giving your college-bound kids their space

    Friday, August 22 2014 9:31 PM EDT2014-08-23 01:31:50 GMT
    Going off to college is an exciting time for the entire family, especially for the upcoming freshman. But with technology, parents can be in touch all the time. What's too much and what's just enough? Freshman move-in day seems to be harder on the parents than the students at Stony Brook University.
    Going off to college is an exciting time for the entire family, especially for the upcoming freshman. But with technology, parents can be in touch all the time. What's too much and what's just enough? Freshman move-in day seems to be harder on the parents than the students at Stony Brook University.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices