Bill would make it illegal for undocumented to use resources - New York News

AZ House Bill 2192 would make it illegal for undocumented immigrants to use public resources

Posted: Updated:
  • Arizona PoliticsMore>>

  • 2014 Arizona Primary election: Track top races

    2014 Arizona Primary election: Track top races

    The poll results are coming in, and some races have already been called.  | Full election results
    The poll results are coming in, and some races have already been called.  | Full election results
  • Doug Ducey wins GOP primary for Arizona governor

    Doug Ducey wins GOP primary for Arizona governor

    State Treasurer and former CEO Doug Ducey won the Republican primary for Arizona governor Tuesday, riding to victory with a campaign that focused on his blend of government and business experience in serving as a state official and building an ice cream company into a national brand.
    State Treasurer and former CEO Doug Ducey won the Republican primary for Arizona governor Tuesday, riding to victory with a campaign that focused on his blend of government and business experience in serving as a state official and building an ice cream company into a national brand.
  • Actor George Takei talks about his documentary and politics

    Actor George Takei talks about his documentary and politics

    Actor and political activist George Takei is premiering his new documentary in Scottsdale.Takei is best-known for playing Hikaru Sulu on the Star Trek series and films.He has ties to Arizona including being married to an Arizonan, who was born in the state, and his mother lived in the White Mountains.
    Actor and political activist George Takei is premiering his new documentary in Scottsdale.Takei is best-known for playing Hikaru Sulu on the Star Trek series and films.He has ties to Arizona including being married to an Arizonan, who was born in the state, and his mother lived in the White Mountains.
  • ImmigrationMore>>

  • Coalition sues over immigrants' access to lawyers

    Coalition sues over immigrants' access to lawyers

    Friday, August 22 2014 6:46 PM EDT2014-08-22 22:46:04 GMT
    A coalition of lawyers filed a lawsuit Friday to halt the quick deportation of Central American woman and children, saying immigrants at a New Mexico detention center don't have proper access to lawyers and are...
    A coalition of lawyers filed a lawsuit Friday to halt the quick deportation of Central American women and children, saying immigrants at a New Mexico detention center don't have proper access to lawyers and are being...
  • Obama weighs broader move on legal immigration

    Obama weighs broader move on legal immigration

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 5:04 PM EDT2014-08-20 21:04:55 GMT
    President Barack Obama is considering key changes in the legal immigration system requested by tech, industry and powerful interest groups.
    President Barack Obama is considering key changes in the nation's immigration system requested by tech, industry and powerful interest groups, in a move that could blunt Republicans' election-year criticism of the...
  • Immigrants found in back of locked rental truck

    Immigrants found in back of locked rental truck

    Federal officials say nine immigrants who entered the United States illegally were found locked inside the cargo area of a rental truck at a Border Patrol checkpoint in southern Arizona.
    Federal officials say nine immigrants who entered the United States illegally were found locked inside the cargo area of a rental truck at a Border Patrol checkpoint in southern Arizona.
PHOENIX (KSAZ) -

He authored a bill that would have required President Obama and other candidates running for president to prove they're U.S. citizens.  

He's also supported SB 1070.

Now a Republican state representative has crafted a new bill that would make it illegal for some undocumented immigrants to use any public resources -- even driving on public roads or using a public bathroom.

But does this bill have a chance?

Rep. Carl Seel introduced HB 2192, which basically makes it a misdemeanor for some people who are in this country illegally to drive down the street or even hop on a city bus.

From the outset, it sounds ridiculous.  How are you going to get stopped for driving down the road?

Well, even Rep. Seel says it's a bill that probably won't even make it anywhere close to becoming law.   

"I mean, I got to be honest with you, a bill like this probably won't get a hearing.  Not to say this bill shouldn't be heard, I just think given how fast we're moving this session, I don't know we'll have time to hear this," said Seel.

Seel admits HB 2192 is not a top priority for lawmakers and while it probably won't ever be discussed in session, many of his constituents are discussing the bill.

"This is so ridiculous that I feel attacked by this because it's going to be really hard to determine who's here legally and who's not.  That's the problem with these types of bills.. that it opens the door to discrimination," said Lydia Guzman of the League of United Latin American Citizens.

The bill makes it a misdemeanor for some in this state to illegally to use any public resource, which by definition, includes driving on a public road or highway, accepting any public benefit, attending public school or using the services of any public entity in this state.

"So it's not for the general public, it's only for the people who have already had their day in court," said Seel.

Seel says the law only applies to people who have been ordered to self-deport, but don't.  But that's not clear in the bill, which sounds like literally anybody on the street could be stopped.

"You might think that in the language and I understand that and that's why I interviewed with people in the media to clarify that it's only people who've had their day in court," said Seel.

Many question how would law enforcement even know that?  That answer appears to be a moot point, just like the bill itself.

"I doubt an issue like this is going to move anywhere, so even though I'm the sponsor of this bill, I'm telling you it's probably not going to move," said Seel.

So what is the point?

"If you've got a court order that says you need to leave the state by a certain date, you should honor that," said Seel.

"This sends that message.. fear sends a message of unwelcomeness," said Guzman.

Rep. Seel says theoretically, if this bill ever became law, it would only apply to about 5,000 people, because again, it would punish only those who've been through the court system for using public resources.

Didn't find what
you were looking for?

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Cristobal to churn surf along Jersey shore

    Cristobal to churn surf along Jersey shore

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 9:14 AM EDT2014-08-27 13:14:52 GMT
    Swimmers and lifeguards are facing a high risk for rip currents along New Jersey beaches. The National Weather Service says Hurricane Cristobal is predicted to pass well to the southeast of the New Jersey coast on Wednesday night. Long period swells will spread out from the storm, churning up the surf along Jersey shore beaches.
    Swimmers and lifeguards are facing a high risk for rip currents along New Jersey beaches. The National Weather Service says Hurricane Cristobal is predicted to pass well to the southeast of the New Jersey coast on Wednesday night. Long period swells will spread out from the storm, churning up the surf along Jersey shore beaches.
  • Hunt for forklift robber

    Hunt for forklift robber

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 9:07 AM EDT2014-08-27 13:07:18 GMT
    Authorities on Long Island are asking for the public's help in finding a forklift thief.  The bright yellow vehicle went missing Monday between 2 p.m. and 5 p.m. from its parking spot near a building in Riverhead. One or more people used a flatbed tow truck with a white cab to remove the Caterpillar forklift. Suffolk County Crime Stoppers is offering a reward of up to $5,000 for information leading to an arrest.
    Authorities on Long Island are asking for the public's help in finding a forklift thief.  The bright yellow vehicle went missing Monday between 2 p.m. and 5 p.m. from its parking spot near a building in Riverhead. One or more people used a flatbed tow truck with a white cab to remove the Caterpillar forklift. Suffolk County Crime Stoppers is offering a reward of up to $5,000 for information leading to an arrest.

  • US marshals in Queens shootout

    US marshals in Queens shootout

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 9:04 AM EDT2014-08-27 13:04:47 GMT
    Authorities say a suspect has been wounded in the hand during a shootout with U.S. marshals who were serving a warrant in Queens. The NYPD says they were assisting the marshals when the gunfire erupted late Tuesday in Springfield Gardens. No law enforcers were hurt.
    Authorities say a suspect has been wounded in the hand during a shootout with U.S. marshals who were serving a warrant in Queens. The NYPD says they were assisting the marshals when the gunfire erupted late Tuesday in Springfield Gardens. No law enforcers were hurt.

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices