Detective won't testify in AZ child death retrial - New York News

Debra Milke case: Judge rules detective can't be forced to testify in retrial

Posted: Updated:
Debra Milke Debra Milke
PHOENIX (KSAZ) -

A judge made a crucial ruling that could sink the murder case against a woman who spent 24 years on death row.

She ruled that prosecutors cannot force a former Phoenix Police detective to testify against Debra Milke after he took the fifth to avoid getting on the witness stand.

It's the worst possible crime you can imagine: A little 4-year-old boy was told he was going to see Santa Claus.  Instead, two men brought him out to the desert and shot him in the head -- killing him.

Those two men, James Styers and Roger Scott, are on death row for the crime.  So was the boy's mother, Debra Milke, but she is now out of prison after a federal appeals court threw out her conviction.

The federal court tossed Milke's conviction because of what it described as misconduct by the man who claims to have taken her confession in 1989 -- former Phoenix Police detective Armando Saldate.

He failed to tape record the confession, there were no witnesses, he threw out his notes and Saldate is accused of lying under oath in other criminal cases.

There was no other evidence against Milke, so she's out on bond.

Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery wants to retry her, but the judge ruled he won't be able to put Saldate back on the stand because he took the fifth to avoid exposing himself to possible perjury charges.

What's next for prosecutors?

"They could appeal that decision to the Court of Appeals to see if the trial judge's decision is going to stand and that is going to make its way up the appellate ladder in due course," said Arizona State University's Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law Professor Sigmund Popko.

If the appeals court upholds the trial judge, the heart of the prosecution case is gone.

If prosecutors have to give up on the prospect of retrying Milke for murder, what will the judgment of history be about the conduct of Detective Saldate?

"Why he put himself in this situation where twenty-some-odd years later, he is facing this is just absolutely ridiculous," said Popko.

Prosecutors had no comment about the judge's ruling.

Milke's defense attorney told me he is hopeful prosecutors will drop the case, but expects they will keep trying to retry her.

Meanwhile, Milke is at an undisclosed location in Maricopa County.

Follow this story:


Didn't find what
you were looking for?

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • August 23, 2014

    Staten Island march traffic and transit advisory

    Staten Island march traffic and transit advisory

    Friday, August 22 2014 3:07 PM EDT2014-08-22 19:07:48 GMT
    The NYPD and the MTA have announced road and transit changes for Staten Island that will be in effect on Saturday, August 23, 2014, due to the scheduled rally in honor of Eric Garner, the Staten Island man who died during an arrest.
    The NYPD and the MTA have announced road and transit changes for Staten Island that will be in effect on Saturday, August 23, 2014, due to the scheduled rally in honor of Eric Garner, the Staten Island man who died during an arrest.
  • 1990 arson-murder rap tossed, Queens man is set free

    1990 arson-murder rap tossed, Queens man is set free

    A former New York businessman whose arson-murder conviction was overturned in the death of his daughter was freed from prison Friday after 24 years behind bars, following a judge's ruling that the case against him had been based on now-debunked arson science.
    A former New York businessman whose arson-murder conviction was overturned in the death of his daughter was freed from prison Friday after 24 years behind bars, following a judge's ruling that the case against him had been based on now-debunked arson science.
  • Sanitation men nearly throw away mayor's piano

    Sanitation men nearly throw away mayor's piano

    Friday, August 22 2014 1:39 PM EDT2014-08-22 17:39:56 GMT
    A piano donated by Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop nearly ended up pushing up daises in a landfill instead of making music in a pedestrian plaza. Fulop gave the upright so residents could play tunes in a pedestrian plaza that opened on Monday.
    A piano donated by Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop nearly ended up pushing up daises in a landfill instead of making music in a pedestrian plaza. Fulop gave the upright so residents could play tunes in a pedestrian plaza that opened on Monday.

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices