Supreme Court case on public prayer underway - New York News

Supreme Court case on public prayer underway

Updated:

By: Herb Scribner, Deseret News

The Supreme Court heard opening arguments Wednesday on a case that could decide the place of prayer in legislative meetings, and what role religion plays in the public sphere.

In the case of Town of Greece v. Galloway, the small New York town was asking the Supreme Court if it was constitutional to hold prayer before its legislative meetings after an appeals court ruled it unconstitutional, according to the Deseret News.

And, according to Reuters, “when the U.S. Supreme Court talks about religion, all hell breaks loose.” One judge of the Supreme Court felt similarly, according to Reuters. "Every time the court gets involved in things like this, it seems to make the problem worse rather than better,” Justice Elena Kagan told Reuters.

“Overall, the justices' remarks were more pessimistic than positive regarding a possible consensus,” reported Reuters. “They voiced frustration with the lawyers who appeared before them and with each other as well.”

Arguments presented “produced an unusually testy oral-argument session on Wednesday that recalled the decades of difficulty Supreme Court justices have had drawing the line between church and state,” according to Reuters.

The Associated Press also released its report of the arguments heard Wednesday.

“The tenor of the argument indicated the justices would not agree with the appellate ruling. But it was not clear what decision they might come to instead,” reported the AP.

The Beckett Fund published the transcript from the opening arguments. Attorney Thomas Hungar explained his case for keeping prayer at the start of legislative meetings in Greece, while the Supreme Court questioned Hungar and fellow attorneys about the constitutionality of prayer in legislative meetings.

Dahlia Lithwick of Slate wrote that religious controversies have been a longstanding tradition in American culture. She also outlined and commented on the oral arguments heard on Wednesday.

“It's all a huge mess with a lot of judicial hair-pulling, and now somebody has to decide whether the town of Greece crossed the line into establishing religion with their several years of exclusively Christian prayer,” she wrote.

USA Today also commented on the court case and called it a tricky one.

"Crafting a constitutionally acceptable rule that will satisfy those of all faiths (and those of no faith) might require the same sort of goodwill and self-restraint that worked to lower the temperature of the school-prayer battle and the so-called war on Christmas," USA Today said.


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Dwayne Johnson hosts 'Hercules' screening for NYC children

    Dwayne Johnson hosts 'Hercules' screening for NYC children

    Thursday, July 24 2014 10:30 PM EDT2014-07-25 02:30:48 GMT
    When he's not slaying three-headed beasts with his olive-wood club, Hercules carves out time for the little people. Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson treated fans from the Harlem Boys and Girls Club and Big Brothers Big Sisters NYC to an advance screening of his new film. I caught up with the larger-than-life action hero after the big surprise.
    When he's not slaying three-headed beasts with his olive-wood club, Hercules carves out time for the little people. Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson treated fans from the Harlem Boys and Girls Club and Big Brothers Big Sisters NYC to an advance screening of his new film. I caught up with the larger-than-life action hero after the big surprise.
  • The Big Idea

    Making New York City more energy efficient

    Making New York City more energy efficient

    Thursday, July 24 2014 10:20 PM EDT2014-07-25 02:20:19 GMT
    More than half the population of New York City rides public transportation to work. No other metropolis in this country even approaches that percentage or the MTA's total number of riders. For that reason, New York likely ranks as the most energy-efficient city in the nation. But what would it take to make the city even more energy-efficient or even self-sufficient?
    More than half the population of New York City rides public transportation to work. No other metropolis in this country even approaches that percentage or the MTA's total number of riders. For that reason, New York likely ranks as the most energy-efficient city in the nation. But what would it take to make the city even more energy-efficient or even self-sufficient?
  • Suffolk County jail warden is highest-paid muni worker in NY

    Suffolk County jail warden is highest-paid muni worker in NY

    Thursday, July 24 2014 6:48 PM EDT2014-07-24 22:48:14 GMT
    New York State NewsNew York State News
    The Empire Center for Public Policy reports 1,803 local government employees outside of New York City have been paid more than Gov. Andrew Cuomo's $179,000 salary in the past year. The report from the fiscally conservative group for the year ending March 31 shows 47 of the 50 highest-paid municipal employees working for police departments or sheriff's offices and each taking home more than $250,000.
    The Empire Center for Public Policy reports 1,803 local government employees outside of New York City have been paid more than Gov. Andrew Cuomo's $179,000 salary in the past year. The report from the fiscally conservative group for the year ending March 31 shows 47 of the 50 highest-paid municipal employees working for police departments or sheriff's offices and each taking home more than $250,000.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices