Herbalife Denies Pyramid Scheme Allegations - New York News

Herbalife Denies Pyramid Scheme Allegations

Posted: Updated:

LOS ANGELES (FOX 11/CNS) - Herbalife has denied allegations in a lawsuit by a former salesmen who contends the nutritional supplement company is running an unlawful pyramid scheme, court papers obtained today showed.

In a 42-page answer to ex-Herbalife distributor Dana Bostick's complaint, the Los Angeles-based company also denies that class action certification is appropriate.

Bostick, a retired Los Angeles general contractor, alleges that Herbalife systematically pays bonuses to distributors based on their recruitment of new salespeople rather than sales.

In a recent ruling, U.S. District Judge Beverly Reid O'Connell denied Herbalife's motion to dismiss the case.

The judge wrote that Herbalife sales people "pay money for the right to sell Herbalife products" while "supervisors pay money to receive recruitment rewards which are unrelated to the sale of products to ultimate users."

If Bostick's assertions are proven, Herbalife could fall under the Federal Trade Commission's definition of an illegal pyramid scheme: one in which those at the top are paid with fees from those recruited at the bottom.

In its answer, filed Tuesday in Los Angeles federal court, Herbalife denies each of Bostick's allegations, even questioning whether the plaintiff is indeed a resident of California.

The company admits only that it is "a network marketing company and has a marketing plan through which individual independent distributors market, promote and sell Herbalife products," according to the filing.

Herbalife also agrees that it entered into a distribution agreement with Bostick in April 2012, but denies that he "accurately and completely summarized" the company's sales and marketing plan, or its policies and rules, in the lawsuit.

Bostick's attorney, Philip D. Dracht, said he was surprised at Herbalife's "seeming inability to admit the most basic facts about their marketing plan -- facts that have already been found by a prior court to be true."

Dracht said he and Herbalife were working out a schedule and expected O'Connell to set a series of court dates in the near future.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Five Guys offers bacon milkshakes

    Five Guys offers bacon milkshakes

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 4:32 PM EDT2014-08-20 20:32:27 GMT
    Burger chain Five Guys is testing the adage that everything tastes better with bacon. It is rolling out a customizable milkshake program and along with bananas, peanut butter, Oreo cookies, salted caramel, you can chose bacon.  Yes that's right: a bacon milkshake.
    Burger chain Five Guys is testing the adage that everything tastes better with bacon. It is rolling out a customizable milkshake program and along with bananas, peanut butter, Oreo cookies, salted caramel, you can chose bacon.  Yes that's right: a bacon milkshake.
  • Serena Williams top seed at U.S. Open

    Serena Williams top seed at U.S. Open

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 2:55 PM EDT2014-08-20 18:55:24 GMT
    No surprise here: defending U.S. Open champion Serena Williams is the top seed at Flushing Meadows this year, the USTA announced. Williams is ranked No. 1 in the world right now. She has won the U.S. Open women's singles title five times, including the last two.
    No surprise here: defending U.S. Open champion Serena Williams is the top seed at Flushing Meadows this year, the USTA announced. Williams is ranked No. 1 in the world right now. She has won the U.S. Open women's singles title five times, including the last two.
  • Reward in probe of shooting of bald eagle in NJ

    Reward in probe of shooting of bald eagle in NJ

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 2:42 PM EDT2014-08-20 18:42:12 GMT
    Federal, state, and humane organizations are offering $7,500 in rewards in the case of the shooting of bald eagle in New Jersey. Someone shot a bald eagle in in Bridgeton City Park back in May, authorities said. The badly wounded bird was found May 20, 2014. Its wounds were so severe that it had to be euthanized.
    Federal, state, and humane organizations are offering $7,500 in rewards in the case of the shooting of bald eagle in New Jersey. Someone shot a bald eagle in in Bridgeton City Park back in May, authorities said. The badly wounded bird was found May 20, 2014. Its wounds were so severe that it had to be euthanized.
  • Los Angeles & SoCal NewsLos Angeles & SoCal NewsMore>>

  • Police Investigating Motorist Wounded In Drive-By Shooting

    Police Investigating Motorist Wounded In Drive-By Shooting

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 3:34 PM EDT2014-08-20 19:34:10 GMT

    A woman wounded by a shotgun blast in a vehicle-to-vehicle shooting as she exited the Golden State (5) Freeway near Griffith Park today was reported in good condition at a hospital.

    A woman wounded by a shotgun blast in a vehicle-to-vehicle shooting as she exited the Golden State (5) Freeway near Griffith Park today was reported in good condition at a hospital.

  • CSUN Announces New Rules For Fraternities To Prevent Hazing

    CSUN Announces New Rules For Fraternities To Prevent Hazing

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 12:02 PM EDT2014-08-20 16:02:01 GMT
    With investigations continuing into a student's death that was blamed by some on hazing, Cal State Northridge officials announced policies today requiring fraternities, sororities and other campus groups to submit plans in advance about membership recruitment and initiation activities.
    With investigations continuing into a student's death that was blamed by some on hazing, Cal State Northridge officials announced policies today requiring fraternities, sororities and other campus groups to submit plans in advance about membership recruitment and initiation activities.
  • Police Search For Suspects Wanted In String Of Home Robberies

    Police Search For Suspects Wanted In String Of Home Robberies

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 10:05 AM EDT2014-08-20 14:05:47 GMT
    Fullerton police are searching for suspects involved in three robberies in the northwest area of town on Sunday night. Police officers first received a report of a robbery in the 1500 block of Avenida Selva, where the suspect encountered a couple, pointed a handgun at them and demanded money.
    Fullerton police are searching for suspects involved in three robberies in the northwest area of town on Sunday night. Police officers first received a report of a robbery in the 1500 block of Avenida Selva, where the suspect encountered a couple, pointed a handgun at them and demanded money.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices