Johnathan Doody juror: All of us except one thought 'guilty' - New York News

Johnathan Doody juror: All of us except one thought he was guilty

Posted: Updated:
PHOENIX -

A judge has declared a mistrial in the 1st degree murder trial of Johnathan Doody. He's the man accused of killing 9 people at a Buddhist temple in the far west valley.

The jury had been in deliberations for about a month now, and simply could not reach a verdict. The judge declared a mistrial.

There was one hold out – one vote of not guilty. The rest thought Doody was guilty.

Before we hear from one of the jurors, I want to give you some perspective on this case. This has been going on for 20 years.

The killings happened in 1991. In 1994 Doody was convicted of 9 counts of 1st degree murder. 16 years later a judge overturned Doody's conviction. And today -- a mistrial.

"Very disappointed with the outcome. We worked a lot of weeks, two months and most of us thought we were going to come to a guilty verdict. But that's the process," says Clifton Kirby, a juror in the Doody trial.

After 7 days of deliberating, juror Clifton Kirby is frustrated the jury couldn't reach a verdict in the Johnathan Doody trial.

"We totaled 11 to one, 11 for guilty, one not guilty."

The one holdout wrote the judge a note saying she didn't "believe some of the evidence in the case." Other jurors felt she wasn't following the rules and refused to deliberate. In the end, Judge Joseph Kreamer declared a mistrial.

"I'd rather not get into that. We all were told to follow the judge's instructions, we had one person we felt that didn't," says Kirby.

Johnathan Doody's dad is surprised there was only one juror who thought his son wasn't guilty.

"At least it's not a guilty verdict and this is just one step closer to my son getting out of jail," says Brian Doody.

"Yeah they're going to do it all over again and I hope it comes out right this time. Everything points to [guilt]. Overwhelming."

That new trial will most likely happen at the end of November.

Doody's attorney says it'll be a different trial and they'll change some of their strategy.

Follow this story

Didn't find what
you were looking for?

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • NYC Council bill to make kids' fast food healthier

    NYC Council bill to make kids' fast food healthier

    Thursday, August 21 2014 12:09 PM EDT2014-08-21 16:09:22 GMT
    Happy Meals might soon need to get healthier.  A New York City councilman is introducing legislation that would set stricter nutritional standards for meals served with toys.
    Happy Meals might soon need to get healthier.  A New York City councilman is introducing legislation that would set stricter nutritional standards for meals served with toys.
  • Fatal boat explosion on Long Island

    Fatal boat explosion on Long Island

    Thursday, August 21 2014 11:59 AM EDT2014-08-21 15:59:22 GMT
    Detectives from the Nassau County Homicide Squad are investigating an explosion that destroyed a boat, burned two docks, and killed the boat's owner in Manorhaven on Wednesday afternoon. Two dock workers and two boaters were gassing up a docked 33-foot Carver motor boat just after 2:45 p.m. when an explosion tore through the boat, setting it and the dock on fire, police said. Hogan was reportedly a former NYPD captain.
    Detectives from the Nassau County Homicide Squad are investigating an explosion that destroyed a boat, burned two docks, and killed the boat's owner in Manorhaven on Wednesday afternoon. Two dock workers and two boaters were gassing up a docked 33-foot Carver motor boat just after 2:45 p.m. when an explosion tore through the boat, setting it and the dock on fire, police said. Hogan was reportedly a former NYPD captain.
  • Chokehold attacker targeting victims in Central Park

    Chokehold attacker targeting victims in Central Park

    Thursday, August 21 2014 11:33 AM EDT2014-08-21 15:33:53 GMT
    The NYPD is looking for a tall, violent thug who is attacking victims in Central Park and dragging them to the ground with chokeholds.The latest attack happened about 12:40 a.m. on Wednesday. Police say the 6' 5" attacker started a conversation with a 47-year-old man in the area of 74th St. and East Drive. He then put the victim in a chokehold, dropped him to the ground and stole his bag.
    The NYPD is looking for a tall, violent thug who is attacking victims in Central Park and dragging them to the ground with chokeholds.The latest attack happened about 12:40 a.m. on Wednesday. Police say the 6' 5" attacker started a conversation with a 47-year-old man in the area of 74th St. and East Drive. He then put the victim in a chokehold, dropped him to the ground and stole his bag.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices