Controversial teacher evaluation system is working in D.C., study says - New York News

Controversial teacher evaluation system is working in D.C., study says

Updated:

By: Celia R. Baker, Deseret News

The controversial teacher evaluation system used by District of Columbia schools seems to be working, according to a new study from the National Bureau of Economic Research. The study showed that using a carrot and a stick - merit pay and threat of firing - motivated improvements by weak teachers and spurred effective teachers to even higher performance levels.

Hundreds of teachers have been fired since the evaluations were implemented four years ago, the Washington Post reported. The study found that the punishments and rewards in the evaluation system inspired two groups of teachers to improve significantly more than others: low-scoring teachers under threat of firing and high-scoring teachers within striking distance of a substantial merit raise, the story continued.

“The study is among the first attempts to understand the effects of the District's teacher evaluation system, known as ­Impact. Then-Chancellor Michelle Rhee introduced the system in 2009, and it was among the first in the nation to link teachers' job security and compensation to student test scores,” the Washington Post reported.

The findings are unlikely to quell criticism of the closely watched evaluation system, according to USA Today, which noted that it allows the District of Columbia to fire teachers rated “ineffective” after just two years. High-performing teachers can qualify for an annual bonus of up to $25,000 or more for their entire careers.

“The researchers found that Impact had an impact within two years: teachers with one ‘minimally effective' rating were much more likely than others to quit, but those who were rated ‘highly effective' stuck around and earned higher scores,” the story said.

Teachers just under the “effective” threshold improved more than those just above it, suggesting that the threat of firing had the intended effect, USA Today said. And, “highly effective” teachers who saw a bonus looming within reach also improved substantially.

The study does not look at whether improvements in teachers' scores translated into more learning for their students, noted Education Week blogger Stephen Sawchuk.

D.C.'s Impact evaluation system rolled out in the 2009-10 school year. It relies on a complex mix of factors for scoring teachers, including multiple observations and measures of student achievement, Sawchuk wrote.

"Though Impact has won accolades in policy circles, some teachers have been less happy with the system," he continued. "In surveys and focus groups, they have complained about feeling monitored, and harbor concerns that it’s harder for teachers in the most challenging school to get top scores on the evaluation."


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    Friday, August 29 2014 8:47 AM EDT2014-08-29 12:47:22 GMT
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
  • Security stepped up for Electric Zoo Festival

    Security stepped up for Electric Zoo Festival

    Friday, August 29 2014 8:34 AM EDT2014-08-29 12:34:04 GMT
    Festival goers to one of the most popular events of the summer in New York City will see major changes this weekend.  The Electric Zoo festival featuring headliner David Guetta takes place Saturday and Sunday on Randall's Island. Organizers are expecting 45,000 people, daily. Last year's party was cut short after the deaths of  Olivia Rotundo, 20, of Providence, R.I. and Jeffrey Russ, 23, of Rochester, N.Y. 
    Festival goers to one of the most popular events of the summer in New York City will see major changes this weekend.  The Electric Zoo festival featuring headliner David Guetta takes place Saturday and Sunday on Randall's Island. Organizers are expecting 45,000 people, daily. Last year's party was cut short after the deaths of  Olivia Rotundo, 20, of Providence, R.I. and Jeffrey Russ, 23, of Rochester, N.Y. 
  • Joan Rivers remains in NYC hospital

    Joan Rivers remains in NYC hospital

    Friday, August 29 2014 7:54 AM EDT2014-08-29 11:54:57 GMT
    Hollywood legend Joan Rivers, 81, remains in critical but stable condition at The Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan. The comedian and TV host was undergoing an outpatient procedure at a clinic on the Upper East Side on Thursday when she went into cardiac arrest and was rushed to the hospital. Her daughter, Melissa Rivers, issued a statement saying her mother was "resting comfortably."

    Hollywood legend Joan Rivers, 81, remains in critical but stable condition at The Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan. The comedian and TV host was undergoing an outpatient procedure at a clinic on the Upper East Side on Thursday when she went into cardiac arrest and was rushed to the hospital. Her daughter, Melissa Rivers, issued a statement saying her mother was "resting comfortably."

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices