When it comes to 1 million frozen embryos, what is ethical? - New York News

When it comes to 1 million frozen embryos, what is ethical?

Updated:

By: Jamshid Ghazi Askar, Deseret News

The writer Paul Ford recently penned a first-person essay for Elle magazine with the headline “Determining the Fate of Frozen Embryos: Do You Know Where Your Children Are?”

“No one knows exactly how many embryos are out there, in liquid nitrogen,” Ford wrote. “The low-end estimate is hundreds of thousands in the United States, but some people say as many as a million. It's a pretty good business … (that) could come to something like $600 million a year in freezing."

After having twins, Ford and his wife struggled to decide what to do with the two frozen embryos they still had “on ice.” Ford outlined several options they considered: keep the embryos frozen (at a cost of $1,200 per year), destroy them, try to have more children, donate the fertilized eggs to scientific research or anonymously donate the embryos to an infertile woman.

In 2003 the global policy think tank RAND Corporation estimated that, as of 2002, “a total of 396,526 embryos have been placed in storage in the United States.”

Building off the RAND data, a 2006 article in Mother Jones magazine attempted to forecast the eventual impact of so many frozen embryos.

“This embryo glut is forcing many people to reconsider whatever they thought they thought about issues such as life and death and choice and reproductive freedom,” Liza Mundy wrote for Mother Jones. “… And so, far from going away, the accumulation of human embryos is likely to grow, and grow, and grow. And in growing, the embryo overstock is likely to change - or at least complicate - the way we collectively think about human life at its earliest stages, and morally what is the right thing to do with it.”

The PBS program “Religion & Ethics Newsweekly” dedicated a 2010 segment to the ethical controversy around donating human embryos to stem cell research. In that report, Harvard Medical School ethics professor Louis Guenin and Richard Doerflinger of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops advocated and opposed, respectively, such research.

Louis Guenin, Harvard Medical School ethicist: “It's a biological fact that those embryos outside of a womb can't mature beyond about two weeks. Knowing that, we have to take account for moral purposes of the duty of beneficence, the duty to come to the aid of those who suffer if we can do so without unreasonable burden.”

Richard Doerflinger, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops: "We are talking here about life, about a human life at a very, very early and undeveloped stage, but human life nonetheless. … When we are talking about stem cell research, we are talking about a way to destroy that life, cut it off at a certain stage for the benefit for others. We think that’s wrong to do that."


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Rocket from Wallops Island seen in NJ

    Rocket from Wallops Island seen in NJ

    Thursday, August 28 2014 7:17 AM EDT2014-08-28 11:17:55 GMT
    NASA is reviewing data from a rocket launch that tested a new sub-payload deployment method for suborbital rockets. NASA says a Black Brant IX suborbital rocket was launched at 5 a.m. Thursday from the agency's Wallops Island Flight Facility on Virginia's Eastern Shore. The new deployment method uses small rocket motors to eject sub-payloads from a rocket's main payload. Thursday's test included releasing vapor traces in space.
    NASA is reviewing data from a rocket launch that tested a new sub-payload deployment method for suborbital rockets. NASA says a Black Brant IX suborbital rocket was launched at 5 a.m. Thursday from the agency's Wallops Island Flight Facility on Virginia's Eastern Shore. The new deployment method uses small rocket motors to eject sub-payloads from a rocket's main payload. Thursday's test included releasing vapor traces in space.
  • Hurricane Cristobal to move toward north Atlantic

    Hurricane Cristobal to move toward north Atlantic

    Thursday, August 28 2014 7:11 AM EDT2014-08-28 11:11:47 GMT
    Hurricane Cristobal is expected to move rapidly toward the north Atlantic, staying away from Bermuda and passing south of Nova Scotia. The hurricane's maximum sustained winds early Thursday are near 75 mph (120 kph) with no significant change in strength forecast over the next two days. The U.S. National Hurricane Center says Cristobal is centered about 285 miles (460 kilometers) northwest of Bermuda and is moving northeast near 29 mph (46 kph).
    Hurricane Cristobal is expected to move rapidly toward the north Atlantic, staying away from Bermuda and passing south of Nova Scotia. The hurricane's maximum sustained winds early Thursday are near 75 mph (120 kph) with no significant change in strength forecast over the next two days. The U.S. National Hurricane Center says Cristobal is centered about 285 miles (460 kilometers) northwest of Bermuda and is moving northeast near 29 mph (46 kph).
  • New stands let US Open fans see stars practice

    New stands let US Open fans see stars practice

    Thursday, August 28 2014 6:55 AM EDT2014-08-28 10:55:01 GMT
    U.S. Open fans can't seem to get enough of practice.  That's right, practice. In a new feature at Flushing Meadows this year, elevated stands loom over five practice courts and allow fans to see stars like Roger Federer and Serena Williams groove their strokes, tinker with strategy and sometimes bicker with coaches.
    U.S. Open fans can't seem to get enough of practice.  That's right, practice. In a new feature at Flushing Meadows this year, elevated stands loom over five practice courts and allow fans to see stars like Roger Federer and Serena Williams groove their strokes, tinker with strategy and sometimes bicker with coaches.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices