Pledge of Allegiance faces another legal challenge - New York News

Pledge of Allegiance faces another legal challenge

Updated:

By: Matthew Brown, Deseret News

For the fourth time in the past decade, the Pledge of Allegiance will be before an appellate court on Wednesday, and the phrase "under God" is again at the heart of the challenge.

But the hearing before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has a different twist. Instead of a making a First Amendment religious violation claim, an anonymous atheist couple says the compulsory recitation of the pledge violates the state's equal protection laws, reports the Christian Post.

"It makes us appear as second class citizens just because we believe something different from the majority," said Roy Speckhardt, executive director for the American Humanist Association, which filed the lawsuit.

The same anti-discrimination theory was used to successfully argue for same-sex marriage in Massachusetts, according to Religion News Service.

"In 2003, Massachusetts' Supreme Judicial Court ruled 4-3 in favor of a same-sex couple seeking the right to marry under the state's equal rights laws," RNS reported. "Their win led to similar successful challenges in other state courts - something that could happen here if judges rule for the plaintiffs."

RNS quoted Eric Rassbach, deputy general counsel for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which is arguing for Knights of Columbus, school children and parents who want to say the pledge at school, saying a similar ruling could spell problems for those defending the pledge.

“You would then see a rash of state court lawsuits challenging the pledge all over the country,” he said. “A win for us would completely avoid that unnecessary harm. And it would affirm that it is not discriminatory to have the words ‘under God' in the pledge.”

The Becket Fund's website summarizes a history of pledge cases beginning in 2000, in which courts have ruled reciting the pledge is constitutional under federal law. The Becket Fund has successfully argued that the pledge is statement of political philosophy not religious belief.

That same argument appeared to have won over Middlesex Superior Court Judge Jane Haggerty who ruled in June 2012 that the Pledge of Allegiance is not a religious practice, but “a voluntary patriotic exercise” that “teach(es) American history and civics.” Judge Haggerty also pointed out that the state allows students to choose not to recite the pledge.

“Members of the American Humanist Association have the right to remain silent if they want to, but they don't have the right to silence everyone else,” said Becket Fund attorney Diana Verm, following the ruling.

The state's Supreme Judicial Court is hearing AHA's appeal of Haggerty's ruling.

"If the federal government decides to write a discriminatory pledge, the Massachusetts Constitution nevertheless protects children in the Commonwealth from the discrimination that would occur from daily recitation of the pledge in classrooms," David Niose, attorney for the AHA, was quoted as saying in rifuture.org, a progressive political website in Rhode Island.


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Dispute over reclining seat diverts flight, again

    Dispute over reclining seat diverts flight, again

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 8:21 AM EDT2014-09-02 12:21:27 GMT
    Delta photoDelta photo
    A Delta Air Lines flight from La Guardia Airport to West Palm Beach, Florida, was diverted to Jacksonville because of a dispute between passengers over a reclining seat. Delta reportedly says the flight was diverted Monday night when a woman got into an argument with a passenger behind her when the woman was trying to recline her seat while the other passenger was trying to sleep on the tray table.
    A Delta Air Lines flight from La Guardia Airport to West Palm Beach, Florida, was diverted to Jacksonville because of a dispute between passengers over a reclining seat. Delta reportedly says the flight was diverted Monday night when a woman got into an argument with a passenger behind her when the woman was trying to recline her seat while the other passenger was trying to sleep on the tray table.
  • High school football player dies

    High school football player dies

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 7:12 AM EDT2014-09-02 11:12:05 GMT
    A 16-year-old high school football player from Staten Island is dead after collapsing during practice Monday, officials said. The teen's father says Miles Kirkland-Thomas collapsed Monday morning during practice for Curtis High School. He was pronounced dead at a hospital.
    A 16-year-old high school football player from Staten Island is dead after collapsing during practice Monday, officials said. The teen's father says Miles Kirkland-Thomas collapsed Monday morning during practice for Curtis High School. He was pronounced dead at a hospital.

  • Bill Clinton to appear in New Haven for fundraiser

    Bill Clinton to appear in New Haven for fundraiser

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 6:24 AM EDT2014-09-02 10:24:23 GMT
    Former President Bill Clinton is scheduled to headline a rally in New Haven to raise money for Democrats running in elections across the country. Clinton is set to appear at the event at the Omni New Haven Hotel on Tuesday. He'll be joined by Gov. Dannel P. Malloy and Lt. Gov. Nancy Wyman, who are seeking re-election in November.
    Former President Bill Clinton is scheduled to headline a rally in New Haven to raise money for Democrats running in elections across the country. Clinton is set to appear at the event at the Omni New Haven Hotel on Tuesday. He'll be joined by Gov. Dannel P. Malloy and Lt. Gov. Nancy Wyman, who are seeking re-election in November.

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices