Should charities give cash to poor people, no strings attached? - New York News

Should charities give cash to poor people, no strings attached?

Updated:

By: Jamshid Ghazi Askar, Deseret News

GiveDirectly, a nonprofit charity founded in 2011, is now drawing a flurry of mainstream media coverage due to its simple-yet-counterintuitive philosophy: Giving cash directly to poor people, no strings attached, is the most efficient form of charity.

“The founders of GiveDirectly (were) a handful of graduate students at Harvard and M.I.T. who were studying the economics of various developing countries,” Jacob Goldstein reported for the New York Times Magazine on Aug. 13. “They chose to situate the charity in Kenya because it was a poor country with a well-developed system for sending money to anyone with a cheap cellphone.

“But they also planned to differentiate their charity; whereas most of the government programs give people money for as long as they qualify, GiveDirectly offers people a one-time grant, spread over the course of several months, and without any requirements.”

On Aug. 16, the public radio program “This American Life” profiled GiveDirectly.

“Giving cash with no strings attached clearly has limits,” Planet Money reporter David Kestenbaum said on “This American Life.” “Even if it works in rural Kenya, it may not work so well in Asia or in urban areas. It won't magically fix all the other things that keep people poor. It won't end civil wars or fix corrupt governments or create new vaccines. But even if it just helps poor people climb up a couple rungs, that would be a huge accomplishment. … There does seem to be this shift that's happening, a shift away from glossy brochures and smiling children and happy anecdotes, a shift toward data. Philanthropy is getting nerdier.”

Months before the New York Times or “This American Life” had reported on GiveDirectly, the Deseret News' Mercedes White wrote a story in April headlined, “No strings attached: How one nonprofit is helping the poor by giving them cash.”

"Because of its rigorous research methods and commitment to outcomes, GiveDirectly has made several powerful allies in the world of development," White reported. "It is currently ranked the second most efficient charity organization by Give Well, a nonprofit rankings group with a reputation for statistical rigor. Google also evaluated the group and came away so impressed that it gave the organization a $2.4 million grant to expand the project to other countries."


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • 5 annoying things about the New York City subway

    5 annoying things about the New York City subway

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 1:07 PM EDT2014-07-30 17:07:01 GMT
    Subway problems are annoying, but it’s just a part of living in New York City. Public transportation isn’t glamorous. It’s a pain. It’s a convenience that can cause an inconvenience. Here is a list of five annoying things about subways in New York City.
    Subway problems are annoying, but it’s just a part of living in New York City. Public transportation isn’t glamorous. It’s a pain. It’s a convenience that can cause an inconvenience. Here is a list of five annoying things about subways in New York City.
  • Terror threats at chemical plants underestimated

    Terror threats at chemical plants underestimated

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 1:05 PM EDT2014-07-30 17:05:38 GMT
    Congressional investigators say the government is underestimating the threat of a chemical attack on America's densely populated cities and has failed to inspect virtually all of the chemical facilities that it...
    Congressional investigators say the government is underestimating the threat of a chemical attack on America's densely populated cities and has failed to inspect virtually all of the chemical facilities that it...
  • Injured detective in Village shootout leaves hospital

    Injured detective in Village shootout leaves hospital

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 12:03 PM EDT2014-07-30 16:03:50 GMT
    The third law enforcement officer injured in a Greenwich Village shootout is getting out of the hospital. The NYPD says Detective Mario Muniz is expected to leave Bellevue Hospital on Wednesday. Police Commissioner William Bratton has said the detective's protective vest may have saved his life.
    The third law enforcement officer injured in a Greenwich Village shootout is out of the hospital. The NYPD says Detective Mario Muniz was expected to leave Bellevue Hospital on Wednesday. Police Commissioner William Bratton has said the detective's protective vest may have saved his life.

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices