Fixing education: Is it possible we're asking the wrong questions? - New York News

Fixing education: Is it possible we're asking the wrong questions?

Updated:

By: Jamshid Ghazi Askar, Deseret News

On Aug. 25, author and journalist Amanda Ripley's new book “The Smartest Kids in the World” made the cover of the New York Times Book Review. The accompanying review of “Smartest Kids” - penned by Annie Murphy Paul, who like Ripley is a fellow at the New America Foundation - is glowing from beginning to end and ebullient in its praise for how Ripley contrasts America's education system with those of Finland, South Korea and Poland.

“The question is whether the startling perspective provided by this masterly book can also generate the will to make changes,” Murphy Paul wrote for the Times. “For all our griping about American education, Ripley notes, we've got the schools we want.”

The Times isn't alone in singing praises for “The Smartest Kids in the World.” Everyone from The Economist to the Huffington Post seems to be commending Ripley for the quality of her reporting and writing. Additionally, the book has a pristine 5-star user rating on Amazon.com.

All of which combines to make this next detail so unusual: Author and education expert Alfie Kohn unleashed a scathing critique of both Ripley and Murphy Paul in a piece he wrote Thursday for the Washington Post with the headline, “Five bad education assumptions the media keeps recycling.”

“The reviewer appears to accept just about all of what she takes to be the author's key assumptions,” Kohn wrote. “The resulting review (titled ‘Likely to Succeed') offers a cautionary collection of problematic premises. …

"One of the key features of the conventional wisdom, the dominant ideology (about education), is that we no longer recognize it as such because we hear it so often. There’s no food for thought here; everyone just knows that our students are lousy, or that raising test scores would improve our economy, or that grit is good; there’s no need to defend these propositions."


Original Post

Copyright 2013 Deseret Digital Media, Inc.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • NYC subway report card

    NYC subway report card

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:09 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:09:16 GMT
    "A mixed bag": That's how the Straphangers Campaign characterizes New York City subways; some good parts and some bad. For example, the C train breaks down most often, not surprising since the line has 50-year-old cars. But C trains were also the cleanest in the transit system.Straphangers said the worst subway trains were the IRT's No. 2.
    "A mixed bag": That's how the Straphangers Campaign characterizes New York City subways; some good parts and some bad. For example, the C train breaks down most often, not surprising since the line has 50-year-old cars. But C trains were also the cleanest in the transit system.Straphangers said the worst subway trains were the IRT's No. 2.
  • Plane evacuated after landing at LaGuardia

    Plane evacuated after landing at LaGuardia

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 4:44 PM EDT2014-07-30 20:44:01 GMT
    A small jetliner made an emergency landing at LaGuardia Airport Wednesday afternoon shortly after taking off, authorities said. American Eagle Flight 3340, carrying 44 passengers and three crew members, departed LaGuardia heading for Knoxville, Tenn., when it had to turn around because of a maintenance issue, the Port Authority said.
    A small jetliner made an emergency landing at LaGuardia Airport Wednesday afternoon shortly after taking off, authorities said. American Eagle Flight 3340, carrying 44 passengers and three crew members, departed LaGuardia heading for Knoxville, Tenn., when it had to turn around because of a maintenance issue, the Port Authority said.
  • Newark police officer shot

    Newark police officer shot

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 4:33 PM EDT2014-07-30 20:33:01 GMT
    A Newark police officer was shot in the leg while on duty Wednesday afternoon. The officer, an 18-year veteran of the force assigned to the 5th Precinct, suffered a gunshot wound in his lower leg, according to the head of the police union. He was brought to University Hospital in Newark and appears to be in "relatively good shape," according to James Stewart Jr., the union head.
    A Newark police officer was shot in the leg while on duty Wednesday afternoon. The officer, an 18-year veteran of the force assigned to the 5th Precinct, suffered a gunshot wound in his lower leg, according to the head of the police union. He was brought to University Hospital in Newark and appears to be in "relatively good shape," according to James Stewart Jr., the union head.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices