Learning you're undocumented, the hard way - New York News

Learning you're undocumented, the hard way

Posted: Updated:
  • ImmigrationMore>>

  • Immigrants found in back of locked rental truck

    Immigrants found in back of locked rental truck

    Federal officials say nine immigrants who entered the United States illegally were found locked inside the cargo area of a rental truck at a Border Patrol checkpoint in southern Arizona.
    Federal officials say nine immigrants who entered the United States illegally were found locked inside the cargo area of a rental truck at a Border Patrol checkpoint in southern Arizona.
  • Some Arivaca residents upset over Border Patrol checkpoint

    Some Arivaca residents upset over Border Patrol checkpoint

    A battle is brewing in one Arizona Border Town over what some residents say is taking over their way of life. They're not talking about migrants crossing the border; their fight is with Border Patrol.
    A battle is brewing in one Arizona Border Town over what some residents say is taking over their way of life. They're not talking about migrants crossing the border; their fight is with Border Patrol.
  • DACA two years later seen as opportunity for some, backdoor amnesty for others

    DACA two years later seen as opportunity for some, backdoor amnesty for others

    It's been two years since President Obama started the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program. It allows undocumented immigrants who came to the United States as kids to work and pursue their education without fear of deportation.It's a day of celebration for some, and also evidence of a continuing deadlock when it comes to immigration in America
    It's been two years since President Obama started the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program. It allows undocumented immigrants who came to the United States as kids to work and pursue their education without fear of deportation.It's a day of celebration for some, and also evidence of a continuing deadlock when it comes to immigration in America
  • Special ReportsMore>>

  • Some Arivaca residents upset over Border Patrol checkpoint

    Some Arivaca residents upset over Border Patrol checkpoint

    A battle is brewing in one Arizona Border Town over what some residents say is taking over their way of life. They're not talking about migrants crossing the border; their fight is with Border Patrol.
    A battle is brewing in one Arizona Border Town over what some residents say is taking over their way of life. They're not talking about migrants crossing the border; their fight is with Border Patrol.
  • Family turns to a psychic to help solve son's murder

    Family turns to a psychic to help solve son's murder

    A family continues to search for answers in the death of their son.Kevin Ore was found shot to death in North Phoenix, just months after he survived cancer.Now his family is asking the public for information to end this investigation and get a killer off the street.
    A family continues to search for answers in the death of their son.Kevin Ore was found shot to death in North Phoenix, just months after he survived cancer.Now his family is asking the public for information to end this investigation and get a killer off the street.
  • Software company aims to map and preserve the USS Arizona wreck

    Software company aims to map and preserve the USS Arizona wreck

    This December will mark the 73rd anniversary of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. It triggered America's entry into the second world war.A symbol of that attack has always been the U.S.S. Arizona, which almost 73 years later remains at the bottom of that shallow harbor, a memorial to the men who died there.
    This December will mark the 73rd anniversary of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. It triggered America's entry into the second world war.A symbol of that attack has always been the U.S.S. Arizona, which almost 73 years later remains at the bottom of that shallow harbor, a memorial to the men who died there.
PHOENIX -

Illegal immigrants, using fake papers or assuming a fake identity to work or go to school. While many are charged with identity theft, as FOX 10's Jill Monier found out, some never knew they were stealing an identity or were even "illegal" to begin with.

21-year-old Estefania Rosas spent 8 months in Estrella Jail.

Like many teens, Rosas started looking for her first job at 15. A family member gave her what she thought was her social security card.

"I didn't know the social was fake," says Rosas. She didn't find out until she started applying for colleges her senior year in high school.

Rosas grew up in America, thinking she was an American. The biggest shock she got was finding out she wasn't.

"I hit a depression at that point… I never thought I was like 'illegal,' you know?"

Her parents brought her to America as an infant and never told her she was born in Mexico.

"I grew up thinking I lived here, you know, I had no reason to ask."

But 3 years later, the 21-year-old still had the fake ID with her, she says, collecting dust.

"I just left them in my wallet, I forgot about it."

In November, Rosas was arrested when a deputy found the fake document during a traffic stop. She was charged with felony forgery and identity theft. Lance Wells is her attorney.

"That was a very common thing. Family got identification, the children got it and used it until they discovered it wasn't valid, if they ever did discover that. Unfortunately some discover it when they get criminal charges pressed against them," says Wells.

Wells says another man he represented was in his 40s when he discovered he was here illegally, only after being arrested.

"Married, had children, going along just fine, a professional, discovered when he applied for a passport his birth certificate was fake. His parents were quite elderly, they said oh yeah we forgot to tell you you're not a U.S. citizen."

Wells said they were able to prove the man didn't know the documents were fake. But Rosas' case was different.

The felonies she was charged with were so severe, she was not allowed to post bond. She was facing deportation if convicted.

"I don't know, it was just hard on me," says Rosas.

Instead of waiting in jail until a trial, she pleaded guilty to reduced misdemeanor charges and was released. But Wells believes prosecutors could be more lenient.

"Charges, for example, brought against these people could be dropped to a lower level so that they qualify to post bail and get out of jail, so we're not using the jail as a holding facility for non-criminal immigrants."

Wells says many with fake IDs use made-up social security numbers that don't belong to anyone to work or go to school.

"Obviously with no intent to defraud anybody."

But others say people's identities are stolen and they become victims of crime. The county attorney's office wouldn't go on camera but a spokesperson issued a statement saying: "The County Attorney has made it clear that our office does not base prosecutorial decisions on an individual's residency status but on an individual's conduct. Identity theft is a serious crime in Arizona and has triggered strong public demand for tougher enforcement. As a result... Arizona has dropped from having the highest rate of identity theft complaints in the country in 2008, to the 8th highest today."

As it turns out, Rosas was granted deferred action the day she was arrested for having the fake ID.

"I just got out, got my social and I started working. My real social now this time," says Rosas.

She's now working legally at a warehouse.

"It feels amazing knowing I can work, provide for myself, help my family."

Recently, local attorneys have been successful in persuading immigration and customs enforcement not to deport some immigrants who were caught using fake IDs to work.

Rosas has plans to go to college now. She wants to be a mechanical engineer.

Didn't find what
you were looking for?

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Sanitation men nearly throw away mayor's piano

    Sanitation men nearly throw away mayor's piano

    Friday, August 22 2014 1:39 PM EDT2014-08-22 17:39:56 GMT
    A piano donated by Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop nearly ended up pushing up daises in a landfill instead of making music in a pedestrian plaza. Fulop gave the upright so residents could play tunes in a pedestrian plaza that opened on Monday.
    A piano donated by Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop nearly ended up pushing up daises in a landfill instead of making music in a pedestrian plaza. Fulop gave the upright so residents could play tunes in a pedestrian plaza that opened on Monday.

  • Fitbit responds to data selling accusations

    Fitbit responds to data selling accusations

    Friday, August 22 2014 12:57 PM EDT2014-08-22 16:57:29 GMT
    The maker of a popular line of wearable fitness-tracking devices says it has never sold personal data to advertisers, contrary to concerns raised by U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer. San Francisco-based Fitbit said Friday that it has clarified its privacy policy to make it clear the company doesn't share information about its users. Schumer raised concerns about the company's privacy policy earlier this month and called for federal rules to allow consumers to protect their data.
    The maker of a popular line of wearable fitness-tracking devices says it has never sold personal data to advertisers, contrary to concerns raised by U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer. San Francisco-based Fitbit said Friday that it has clarified its privacy policy to make it clear the company doesn't share information about its users. Schumer raised concerns about the company's privacy policy earlier this month and called for federal rules to allow consumers to protect their data.
  • 50,000 bees living in NYC ceiling

    50,000 bees living in NYC ceiling

    Friday, August 22 2014 12:27 PM EDT2014-08-22 16:27:29 GMT
    A Queens woman had some unexpected roommates living in her apartment: 50,000 bees. Beekeepers reportedly removed the swarm from Frieda Turkmenilli's ceiling this week after her neighbors in Queens alerted the building manager. Turkmenilli says she saw only a few bees buzzing around over the last few weeks and never realized how many had taken up residence right above her head.
    A Queens woman had some unexpected roommates living in her apartment: 50,000 bees. Beekeepers reportedly removed the swarm from Frieda Turkmenilli's ceiling this week after her neighbors in Queens alerted the building manager. Turkmenilli says she saw only a few bees buzzing around over the last few weeks and never realized how many had taken up residence right above her head.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices