Yarnell Hill fire: Controversy over comments from FS official - New York News

Forestry official says hot shot leader "put people at risk"

Posted: Updated:
Eric Marsh Eric Marsh
YARNELL, Ariz. -

Today marks the 1 month anniversary of the day 19 Granite Mountain Hot Shots were killed battling the Yarnell Hill Fire. The elite group became trapped when winds shifted on them and cut off their escape route.

At least one state forestry official is saying mistakes were made that day -- and that the team's leader, Eric Marsh, didn't follow protocols.

These claims are being made in an online news article that quotes the deputy director of the Arizona Department of Forestry.

He has been a major figure in the investigation. In fact just last week he was part of a group that took the media to the spot where the hot shots died. In the article he says mistakes were made.

The article quotes Deputy State Forestry Director Jerry Payne as saying Eric Marsh, the most senior member of the Granite Mountain Hot Shots was acting as the "division supervisor" and broke several basic wildfire rules.

Payne is quoted saying: "The division supervisor broke those rules and put those people at risk."

The article was written by longtime investigator reporter John Dougherty for investigativemedia.com.

Payne told the writer that it appears the basic rules Marsh violated were rules like -- not knowing the location of the fire and not having a spotter observing the fire.

You remember the hot shot crew's lookout left his post because it became too dangerous. He survived.

The others died trying to escape the fast moving fire. Payne reportedly said that Marsh was trying to lead his crew to a safe zone but to travel through a heavily vegetated box canyon to get there…

"It was a calculated risk. They didn't even make it halfway," Payne is quoted. "It was a serious miscalculation, in my opinion. It was an honest mistake."

Today, the Prescott Fire Chief lashed out at Payne. He calls his comments unethical.

"I think it is one of the most disgusting incidents that I have had in my entire career," said Dan Fraijo.

"Eric Marsh was one of the most intelligent and hardest working people. He took his profession to the science level. I have stellar reports on him. I can tell you that if he was here right now I would do the same things that most of our people would do, I would follow him anywhere. This is a terrible insult to him and to his family and it is unfounded."

"His comments were unauthorized and do not represent the position of the state forestry. I don't think the conversation was intended to state a position for state forestry and for that Mr. Payne is extremely sorry and regretful," said Jim Paxon, spokesman for Game and Fish.

Writer John Dougherty told us he stands by his story (it can be found here: http://bit.ly/17f8aoz).

The official investigation has not been completed.

Statement by Forestry Division official Scott Hunt

State Forester Scott Hunt wants to make it clear that State Forestry has taken no position on the causes of the fatalities and awaits the results of the two independent investigations that are currently being conducted by the Serious Accident Investigation Team and Arizona Department of Occupational Safety and Health. State Forestry apologizes for Mr. Payne's inappropriate expression of opinion as fact and unfounded speculation that prejudges the ultimate conclusion of the investigation. The investigation reports are expected to be released in the coming months.

Didn't find what
you were looking for?

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Mayor pushes back pre-k concerns

    Mayor pushes back pre-k concerns

    Thursday, August 28 2014 10:16 PM EDT2014-08-29 02:16:46 GMT
    Mayor Bill de Blasio, educators and city leaders gathered at p.s. 307 in Brooklyn on Thursday to talk with pride about more than 50,000 kids who have enrolled in pre-kindergarten. Universal full-day pre-k was a platform of his campaign when he ran for mayor.Schools Chancellor Carmen Farina also feels the pre-k program is ready for launch.
    Mayor Bill de Blasio, educators and city leaders gathered at p.s. 307 in Brooklyn on Thursday to talk with pride about more than 50,000 kids who have enrolled in pre-kindergarten. Universal full-day pre-k was a platform of his campaign when he ran for mayor.Schools Chancellor Carmen Farina also feels the pre-k program is ready for launch.
  • Revel closing, but property fight goes on

    Revel closing, but property fight goes on

    Thursday, August 28 2014 9:34 PM EDT2014-08-29 01:34:07 GMT
    A casino piano tuner in Atlantic City is fighting the state's attempt to seize his late parents' house as part of a redevelopment project connected to the closing Revel Hotel Casino. Charlie Birnbaum says the house in the shadow of the failed casino was his father's livelihood. He says he is attached to the home, even though his mother was killed there in 1998.
    A casino piano tuner in Atlantic City is fighting the state's attempt to seize his late parents' house as part of a redevelopment project connected to the closing Revel Hotel Casino. Charlie Birnbaum says the house in the shadow of the failed casino was his father's livelihood. He says he is attached to the home, even though his mother was killed there in 1998.
  • 'Resting comfortably'

    Joan Rivers rushed to NYC hospital

    Joan Rivers rushed to NYC hospital

    Thursday, August 28 2014 9:22 PM EDT2014-08-29 01:22:56 GMT
    Joan Rivers was reportedly rushed to a hospital in New York City Thursday morning after she stopped breathing during a throat surgery.  The TV host and comedian was apparently undergoing the procedure in a clinic when she stopped breathing.
    Joan Rivers was reportedly rushed to a hospital in New York City Thursday morning after she stopped breathing during a throat surgery.  The TV host and comedian was apparently undergoing the procedure in a clinic when she stopped breathing.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices