NJ Supreme Court overturns award in dunes case - New York News

NJ Supreme Court overturns award in dunes case

Posted: Updated:

By WAYNE PARRY

HARVEY CEDARS, N.J. (AP) — New Jersey's highest court on Monday overturned a $375,000 jury award given to an elderly couple who complained that a protective sand dune behind their house blocked their ocean views.

In a ruling seen as a wider victory for towns that want to build barriers to protect themselves from catastrophic storms, the state Supreme Court faulted a lower court for not allowing jurors to consider the dune's benefits in calculating its effect on property value. The high court ruled that those protective benefits should have been considered along with the loss of the ocean views.

The sand dune in question saved the elderly couple's home from destruction in Superstorm Sandy in October.

The 5-year-old case is being closely watched at the Jersey shore, which was battered by Sandy. Officials want to build protective dune systems along the state's entire 127-mile coastline, but towns fear they won't be able to if many homeowners hold out for large payouts as compensation for lost views.

"Had we lost this case, I think beach replenishment would have been (over) in New Jersey," Harvey Cedars Mayor Jonathan Oldham said. "We're very pleased with the court's ruling and look forward to competing with a fair set of rules. I'm happy for the whole island."

The homeowners, Harvey and Phyllis Karan, had rejected the town's offer of $300 in compensation for their lost views and insisted on a trial. Their Long Beach Island home is worth close to $2 million.

"Although the jury found that the Karans' property decreased in value because the dune obstructed their view, a buyer would likely also consider the value provided by the dune in shielding the property from destruction," the court wrote in its opinion. "The court did not allow the jury to consider evidence that the dunes — constructed at public expense to protect the island's homes from minor and catastrophic storms— enhanced the value of the Karans' property.

"The jury awarded the Karans $375,000 in damages, premised mostly on the loss of their oceanfront view," the justices wrote. "Homeowners are entitled to the fair market value of their loss, not to a windfall, not to a payout that disregards the home's enhanced value resulting from a public project."

The court said a new trial is needed where jurors would be told to also consider the dune's benefits. There was no immediate indication when a new trial might be held.

Gov. Chris Christie has repeatedly ridiculed homeowners' complaints about dunes blocking their views and called the Karans' and others in their circumstances "knuckleheads" during a recent public meeting on Long Beach Island. The state is trying to get oceanfront property owners all along the coast to sign easements allowing the government access to small strips of their land to carry out the dune projects.

"The Supreme Court's decision embraces what Gov. Christie has been arguing ever since Sandy: that oceanfront properties protected from destruction are safer and more valuable than those that are not," Christie spokesman Michael Drewniak said.

Government-funded dune systems "benefit everyone, including holdouts who selfishly refuse to provide easements to protect not just their own homes but the homes and businesses inland of them as well," Drewniak said. "Those holdouts are the greatest beneficiaries of dune systems and are not entitled to a windfall at the public's expense."

Peter Wegener, an attorney for the Karans, argued before the court that the view is a valuable commodity that figures prominently in the selling prices of homes near the beach. He said he was not surprised at the outcome, given the skepticism several of the justices voiced toward the Karans' legal position during oral arguments in May.

"It seems to sweep away 150 years of jurisprudence in an attempt to reach a solution to a political problem," he said of the ruling. "Obviously the impact of the storm had a big impact on the court's opinion."

Neither Wegener nor Oldham, the Harvey Cedars mayor, could say whether the ruling might help or harm the chances of a negotiated settlement in the case.

Jeff Tittel, director of the New Jersey Sierra Club, hailed the ruling as an important step toward safeguarding the Jersey shore, parts of which remain vulnerable to future storms.

"Many of the areas without dunes got devastated, with these areas now wanting money to rebuild, but still do not want to put in dunes," he said. "We cannot rebuild the shore smarter and better without building dunes, so this decision is important on how we rebuild our coast and natural systems."

___

Wayne Parry can be reached at http://twitter.com/WayneParryAC

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press.

  • New Jersey NewsNew Jersey NewsMore>>

  • Undercover police officer shot during drug buy in New Jersey

    Undercover police officer shot during drug buy in New Jersey

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 5:45 PM EDT2014-04-22 21:45:36 GMT
    An undercover narcotics police officer was shot during a shootout with a suspect in a parking lot in Bergen County, N.J., Tuesday afternoon, according to a source. The shooting happened at about 1:45 p.m. at a Walmart and Marshalls shopping center in Garfield. The cop was hot in the hip and ankle, and was taken into surgery at Hackensack University Hospital, the source said.
    An undercover narcotics police officer was shot during a shootout with a suspect in a parking lot in Bergen County, N.J., Tuesday afternoon, according to a source. The shooting happened at about 1:45 p.m. at a Walmart and Marshalls shopping center in Garfield. The cop was hot in the hip and ankle, and was taken into surgery at Hackensack University Hospital, the source said.
  • Hoboken a top place for recent college grads to live, report says

    Hoboken a top place for recent college grads to live, report says

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 12:46 PM EDT2014-04-22 16:46:32 GMT
    Hoboken's vibrant downtown, access to more than 100,000 job openings and the large amount of rentals available rank the city among the best places for new college grads to live in the country, according to Livability.com. Hoboken ranked No. 6 in Livability.com's recently released list of the "Top 10 Best Cities for New College Grads 2014."
    Hoboken's vibrant downtown, access to more than 100,000 job openings and the large amount of rentals available rank the city among the best places for new college grads to live in the country, according to Livability.com. Hoboken ranked No. 6 in Livability.com's recently released list of the "Top 10 Best Cities for New College Grads 2014."
  • Melissa Gorga: RHONJ season 6 is a 'whole new show'

    Melissa Gorga: RHONJ season 6 is a 'whole new show'

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 12:46 PM EDT2014-04-22 16:46:02 GMT
    Melissa Gorga says the upcoming season 6 of The Real Housewives of New Jersey will be a “whole new show,” according to a report on allthingsrh.com. The Franklin Lakes resident opened up about the new season – which will be sans longtime cast members Jacqueline Laurita and Caroline Manzo – at The Tampa Home And Garden Show, the report said.
    Melissa Gorga says the upcoming season 6 of The Real Housewives of New Jersey will be a “whole new show,” according to a report on allthingsrh.com. The Franklin Lakes resident opened up about the new season – which will be sans longtime cast members Jacqueline Laurita and Caroline Manzo – at The Tampa Home And Garden Show, the report said.
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Caesars enters New York casino competition

    Caesars enters New York casino competition

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 10:52 PM EDT2014-04-23 02:52:22 GMT
    Caesars Entertainment entered the competition to open a casino in upstate New York on Tuesday with a proposal to build a $750 million complex 50 miles north of New York City. The complex would include a casino, a hotel and a meeting space and would be located in Woodbury, in Orange County. The Las Vegas-based Caesars, which operates 52 casinos around the world, has submitted a $1 million casino license application fee to state gambling regulators.
    Caesars Entertainment entered the competition to open a casino in upstate New York on Tuesday with a proposal to build a $750 million complex 50 miles north of New York City. The complex would include a casino, a hotel and a meeting space and would be located in Woodbury, in Orange County. The Las Vegas-based Caesars, which operates 52 casinos around the world, has submitted a $1 million casino license application fee to state gambling regulators.
  • Hoax 'swatting' call sends dozens of cops to LI home

    Hoax 'swatting' call sends dozens of cops to LI home

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 10:43 PM EDT2014-04-23 02:43:53 GMT
    Heavily armed police officers descended on a home in Long Beach, Long Island, Tuesday afternoon thinking they might find a grisly murder scene. Instead they found a terrified woman who had no clue what they were talking about and her teenaged son playing video games. "We received a phone call from a gentleman who stated he had just shot his mother and his brother," Long Beach Police Commissioner Michael Tangney said. "Unfortunately, this is a terrible national problem for law enforcement."
    Heavily armed police officers descended on a home in Long Beach, Long Island, Tuesday afternoon thinking they might find a grisly murder scene. Instead they found a terrified woman who had no clue what they were talking about and her teenaged son playing video games. "We received a phone call from a gentleman who stated he had just shot his mother and his brother," Long Beach Police Commissioner Michael Tangney said. "Unfortunately, this is a terrible national problem for law enforcement."
  • NYPD Twitter hashtag backfires

    NYPD Twitter hashtag backfires

    Tuesday, April 22 2014 9:14 PM EDT2014-04-23 01:14:35 GMT
    An NYPD plan intended to better connect with the community seems to have backfired a bit. The police department asked its twitter followers to share pictures of themselves with New York City police officers using the hashtag "myNYPD." Some did share nice pictures, but others not so much.Some of the first pictures posted showed regular citizens standing with very friendly looking police officers.
    An NYPD plan intended to better connect with the community seems to have backfired a bit. The police department asked its twitter followers to share pictures of themselves with New York City police officers using the hashtag "myNYPD." Some did share nice pictures, but others not so much.Some of the first pictures posted showed regular citizens standing with very friendly looking police officers.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices