Bakery Refuses To Make A Cake For Same-Sex Couple - New York News

Bakery Refuses To Make A Cake For Same-Sex Couple

Posted: Updated:

A Colorado couple will not have a cake for their wedding, because the shop they want it from turned them away. 

Why?  Well, the shop's owner says they have their sexual orientation to thank for that.

Now, this same-sex couple is fighting back, after exposing the bakery's policy in an experiment of their own.

Stephanie Schmalz and her partner, Jeanine, wanted to order a cake to celebrate their commitment ceremony.    They contacted the Masterpiece Cake Shop in Lakewood, Colorado, but the store refused to take their order.    The store has a strict policy against selling cakes for same-sex weddings.    Stephanie then tried a little experiment.    She called the bakery back,  pretending to be someone else, and asked for a cake for a dog wedding.  Without hesitation the owner agreed to make it. 

Jeanine says she couldn't believe what had just happened.   "My goal is not to see somebody get out of business, but at the same time,  if you sell cakes, you sell cakes.  It shouldn't have anything to do with anything about me - where I live, what I do, what color skin I have, anything else."

This cake shop has made headlines before.  It turned down several other same-sex couples celebrating their unions. 

Jack Phillips, the bakery's owner, says he has no problem with lesbian and gay customers or staff members, but he draws the line at gay marriage.  He says he rather shut down his bakery than compromise his beliefs.

The Colorado attorney general's office has filed a formal complaint against the bakery.

A judge will decide if what the bakery is doing is discrimination.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • 8 fined $144,500 in Long Island cheating scandals

    8 fined $144,500 in Long Island cheating scandals

    State records show two administrators and six educators were fined a total of $145,500 in connection with two separate cheating scandals in Glen Cove City schools on Long Island.
    State records show two administrators and six educators were fined a total of $145,500 in connection with two separate cheating scandals in Glen Cove City schools on Long Island.
  • FEMA chief questioned over Sandy claims

    FEMA chief questioned over Sandy claims

    Hurricane Sandy damage in Mantoloking, N.J.Hurricane Sandy damage in Mantoloking, N.J.
    The head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency has asked an independent watchdog to examine whether the flood-insurance program is shortchanging Superstorm Sandy victims.
    The head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency has asked an independent watchdog to examine whether the flood-insurance program is shortchanging Superstorm Sandy victims.
  • Teen pleads guilty in 1 World Trade Center climb

    Teen pleads guilty in 1 World Trade Center climb

    A teenager who made a surreptitious climb to the top of the 1 World Trade Center tower has pleaded guilty in an escapade that fanned concerns about security at the nation's tallest building.
    A teenager who made a surreptitious climb to the top of the 1 World Trade Center tower has pleaded guilty in an escapade that fanned concerns about security at the nation's tallest building.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices