Medical Ethicist Explains Organ Transplant Dilemma - New York News

Medical Ethicist Explains Organ Transplant Dilemma

Posted: Updated:
CAMDEN, N.J. -

Sarah Murnaghan may have only weeks to live. Tuesday morning that fact became clearer than ever to her family. According to Sharon Ruddock, Sarah's Aunt, "This morning she woke up and her lips were blue and she was very gray."

Doctors were able to stabilize the 10-year-old, but the question now: for how long? That's why Sarah's parents want the HHS Secretary, Kathleen Sebelius, to lift the age restriction that won't allow Sarah to receive an adult lung. Right now only children 12 and older qualify.

According to Sharon Ruddock, Sarah's Aunt, "What we want is for their policy to change so they don't discriminate against children because of age."

Weighing in on the ethics of the case is Dr. Anthony Mazzarelli, Medical Ethicist at Cooper University Hospital, "I think it's wrong, I do. I think it's wrong because I think we should go by sickness, because we can use the lobe of a lung from an adult to transplant to a child, even if potentially that income won't be quite as good..."

Sarah's family wants the age policy to be lifted for all children, immediately, so the sickest kids, like Sarah, can compete with adults to get a lung. But even that action would cause an ethical dilemma, according to Dr. Mazzarelli.

"If I'm Kathleen Sebelius, I think I acknowledge there's a problem with the system, and I don't think I make an exception for who this little girl is, as much as I would love to tell you that I would."

She's a little girl with a sweet innocent face. How could anyone choose to let her die?

And Dr. Mazzarelli agrees, "I believe she should be in that system with adults, particularly because when you look at a lot of those adults, it's through actions of their own such as smoking, that they're in the need of having a transplant, vs. a 10 year old who did nothing and needs that lung."

But as unfair as the situation may seem for Sarah, suspending the current policy while it's under review may not be fair either-- according to this medical ethicist.

"The lives we're not talking about are the people who don't get a lung, because we've changed the rules to allow these certain individuals in, right? We have to be careful that we don't so focus on the names that we know, that we don't think about the names that we don't know."

Certainly, Sarah's name and story are now familiar locally, and increasingly, nationwide.

Dr. Mazzarelli elaborates, "It becomes very seductive to want to give that resource out to the face that you know needs it versus thinking about what's the most fair system."

Dr. Mazzarelli does agree the current organ donor policy needs to be reviewed. But he says that process should happen first, before any changes are made.

"We have to look back at why that rule was made, what technology has changed since that point, and I think it's something that you can probably do in a fairly timely manner, but you really have to think about the overall impact when you start making exceptions to a system that's already set up."

  • Sarah's FightMore>>

  • Sarah Murnaghan Leaves CHOP, Arrives Home!

    Sarah Murnaghan Leaves CHOP, Arrives Home!

    Wednesday, December 18 2013 12:12 PM EST2013-12-18 17:12:02 GMT
    After several months in the hospital and agonizing surgeries, 11-year-old Sarah Murnaghan is finally going home today.
    After several months in the hospital and agonizing surgeries, 11-year-old Sarah Murnaghan is finally home!
  • Sarah Murnaghan Breaths On Her Own

    Sarah Murnaghan Breaths On Her Own

    Tuesday, September 17 2013 8:36 PM EDT2013-09-18 00:36:11 GMT
    In the video, Sarah's aunt asks Sarah, "Are you off your machines?" To which Sarah eventually responds, "I feel fine."
    In the video, Sarah's aunt asks Sarah, "Are you off your machines?" To which Sarah eventually responds, "I feel fine."
  • Sarah Murnaghan Recovering At Home

    Sarah Murnaghan Recovering At Home

    Tuesday, September 17 2013 8:26 PM EDT2013-09-18 00:26:48 GMT
    Sarah's mom says she's looking forward to playing with her friends, singing and playing soccer. She'll basically enjoy the normal life of an 11-year-old.
    Sarah's mom says she's looking forward to playing with her friends, singing and playing soccer. She'll basically enjoy the normal life of an 11-year-old.
  • Local NewsMore>>

  • 1 Person Killed in Bethel Township Accident

    1 Person Killed in Bethel Township Accident

    Monday, September 1 2014 10:03 PM EDT2014-09-02 02:03:33 GMT
    1 person was killed in an accident in Bethel Township, Delaware County on Monday evening.Initial reports indicate that a vehicle may have hit a tree and overturned. It happened on the 3300 block of Foulk Road around 8:30pm.Foulk Road was closed for several hours while police investigated the crash scene.Stay with Fox 29 News for updates.
    1 person was killed in an accident in Bethel Township, Delaware County on Monday evening.Initial reports indicate that a vehicle may have hit a tree and overturned. It happened on the 3300 block of Foulk Road around 8:30pm.Foulk Road was closed for several hours while police investigated the crash scene.Stay with Fox 29 News for updates.
  • Council Rock South Mourns The Loss Of Three Classmates

    Council Rock South Mourns The Loss Of Three Classmates

    Monday, September 1 2014 5:23 PM EDT2014-09-01 21:23:09 GMT
    Three boys from Council Rock South High School died over the weekend when their SUV overturned.
    Three boys from Council Rock South High School died over the weekend when their SUV overturned.
  • Hamels, 3 Phillies relievers no-hit Braves

    Hamels, 3 Phillies relievers no-hit Braves

    Monday, September 1 2014 4:42 PM EDT2014-09-01 20:42:38 GMT
    Cole Hamels and three Philadelphia Phillies relievers combined to pitch a no-hitter Monday, beating the Atlanta Braves 7-0.
    Cole Hamels and three Philadelphia Phillies relievers combined to pitch a no-hitter Monday, beating the Atlanta Braves 7-0.
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Hope's Land of Candy

    Hope's Land of Candy

    Monday, September 1 2014 8:13 PM EDT2014-09-02 00:13:34 GMT
    Step through the doors of Hope's Land of Candy in Island Park, Long Island and you''ll be taking a trip back in time. There's no WIFI but they do have a Victrola piano. And then there's the candy.. lots and lots of it.
    Step through the doors of Hope's Land of Candy in Island Park, Long Island and you''ll be taking a trip back in time. There's no WIFI but they do have a Victrola piano. And then there's the candy.. lots and lots of it.
  • Subway bedbug infestations on the rise

    Subway bedbug infestations on the rise

    Monday, September 1 2014 6:48 PM EDT2014-09-01 22:48:09 GMT
    It appears the subway bedbug problem we've been reporting is getting worse. Commuters already have to contend with sweltering platforms, scurrying rats and packed train cars, and now there's another transit woe: fear of bedbugs.
    It appears the subway bedbug problem we've been reporting is getting worse. Commuters already have to contend with sweltering platforms, scurrying rats and packed train cars, and now there's another transit woe: fear of bedbugs.
  • West Indian Day Parade steps off amid shootings

    West Indian Day Parade steps off amid shootings

    Monday, September 1 2014 6:05 PM EDT2014-09-01 22:05:47 GMT
    The West Indian Day Parade is supposed to be a time of fun and excitement in celebration of Caribbean culture. However, several shootings near the parade has turned it into a day of tragedy for some.
    The West Indian Day Parade is supposed to be a time of fun and excitement in celebration of Caribbean culture. However, several shootings near the parade has turned it into a day of tragedy for some.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices