Lawsuit against Scottsdale Police alleges faulty DUI equipment - New York News

Lawsuit against Scottsdale Police alleges faulty DUI equipment

Posted: Updated:
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -

Several DUI cases out of Scottsdale may be in jeopardy all because of possible glitch at the Scottsdale crime lab. We spoke to one woman whose case was tossed out after doubt was cast on the results of her blood test.

Christy Allen Lee was pulled over by a Scottsdale Police officer. The officer asked her to take a blood test to determine if she was driving under the influence of alcohol.

"I agreed to the blood test because I knew I had had one drink 4 hours prior to driving so I knew it wasn't going to register," says Lee.

But the results showed something different.

"For them to come to me and say it registered, I think it was .134 which I'm sorry in my size, it's not going to happen."

She protested, to no avail.

"Their only response was, you need to fight it then get a lawyer." So she did.

"There is a big problem there," says attorney Craig Rosenstein.

Attorney Craig Rosenstein took Lee's case and was able to raise enough doubt about the blood result at trial that a jury found her not guilty.

This wasn't the first time that Rosenstein suspected results out of the Scottsdale crime lab. And other attorneys he spoke to had similar concerns.

"It appears the Scottsdale crime lab has been using faulty machines for the last 4 years and getting results that have been questionable at best."

We contacted Scottsdale police department about that allegation. They released a statement which read in part: "The Scottsdale Police Lab is an accredited testing forensics lab. We were first accredited in 1996. We have met or exceed the rigorous standards set by American Society of Crime Lab Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board every year since then. We continue to adhere to the standards."

Lee's life was turned upside down because of the arrest.

"I lost a job because of it, which was a real hardship I'm a single parent. At the time I was going through a custody case that was dependent on the credibility as a parent. It cost me a fortune. Even to this day the actual arrest is not expunged from my record."

On Monday, a court hearing is scheduled where a judge will be looking at 11 DUI cases out of Scottsdale.


  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Aire Ancient Baths

    A relaxing bathhouse in busy Tribeca

    A relaxing bathhouse in busy Tribeca

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 10:29 PM EDT2014-07-30 02:29:51 GMT
    Deep beneath the hustle and bustle of Tribeca lies a modern-day oasis brimming with old world charm: Aire Ancient Baths, my new favorite city escape. The breathtaking spa is illuminated by hundreds of candles and smells of invigorating eucalyptus. For around $80 you can bathe in the tranquil blue pools for 90 minutes and find the temperature that's right for you.
    Deep beneath the hustle and bustle of Tribeca lies a modern-day oasis brimming with old world charm: Aire Ancient Baths, my new favorite city escape. The breathtaking spa is illuminated by hundreds of candles and smells of invigorating eucalyptus. For around $80 you can bathe in the tranquil blue pools for 90 minutes and find the temperature that's right for you.
  • NYC stores with no signs feed curiosity

    NYC stores with no signs feed curiosity

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 8:40 PM EDT2014-07-30 00:40:09 GMT
    From coffee shops in Brooklyn to restaurants in Manhattan, we find speakeasies standing out by blending in. When people in Bushwick want a green machine juice blend they visit Leticia Castillo's Owl Juice Pub. But first they must find the owl. "We been doing fine without a sign," Castillo says.
    From coffee shops in Brooklyn to restaurants in Manhattan, we find speakeasies standing out by blending in. When people in Bushwick want a green machine juice blend they visit Leticia Castillo's Owl Juice Pub. But first they must find the owl. "We been doing fine without a sign," Castillo says.
  • NY brothers invent machine that makes CPR easier

    NY brothers invent machine that makes CPR easier

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 6:40 PM EDT2014-07-29 22:40:57 GMT
    Only 10 percent of people who get CPR from a bystander actually survive. But two young men in Westchester County have now patented a device that could dramatically increase those odds and save lives. John and Chris DiCapua's sitting room in their parents' Westchester County home has had a unique guest lying around for quite a while now: a CPR dummy. What began as an idea from their time as Boy Scouts is now a device that could potentially save lives.
    Only 10 percent of people who get CPR from a bystander actually survive. But two young men in Westchester County have now patented a device that could dramatically increase those odds and save lives. John and Chris DiCapua's sitting room in their parents' Westchester County home has had a unique guest lying around for quite a while now: a CPR dummy. What began as an idea from their time as Boy Scouts is now a device that could potentially save lives.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices