Maricopa top lawyer: I'm not targeting immigrants - New York News

Maricopa top lawyer: I'm not targeting immigrants

Posted: Updated:
  • ImmigrationMore>>

  • Deportations down 20 percent, fewest since 2007

    Deportations down 20 percent, fewest since 2007

    Friday, September 12 2014 4:29 PM EDT2014-09-12 20:29:39 GMT
    President Barack Obama has quietly slowed deportations by nearly 20 percent while delaying plans to act on his own potentially to shield millions of immigrants from expulsion.
    President Barack Obama has quietly slowed deportations by nearly 20 percent while delaying plans to act on his own potentially to shield millions of immigrants from expulsion.
  • Report: Border Patrol housing poorly planned

    Report: Border Patrol housing poorly planned

    A report by the federal Department of Homeland Security has found the parent agency of the Border Patrol mishandled a housing project for agents in Ajo, Arizona.
    A report by the federal Department of Homeland Security has found the parent agency of the Border Patrol mishandled a housing project for agents in Ajo, Arizona.
  • US sharply cutting deportations

    APNewsBreak: US sharply cutting deportations

    While debate continues on slowing deportations, the Obama administration already is on pace to deport the fewest number of immigrants since at least 2007. That's according to federal figures obtained by The...
    While debate continues on slowing deportations, the Obama administration already is on pace to deport the fewest number of immigrants since at least 2007. That's according to federal figures obtained by The Associated...
PHOENIX -

Is there a double standard when it comes to prosecuting people using fake identification in Maricopa County?

A group says County Attorney Bill Montgomery comes down hard when illegal immigrants are caught, but gives others a free pass.

This week Tempe police announced they seized 1,761 fake ID's from underage drinkers in the past year, but only 224 of them were given misdemeanors. The others were only given citations.

Immigrants' rights group point out the when illegal immigrants are busted in workplace raids, they are charged with felonies, Tempe police seized almost 2,000 fake ID's along Mill Avenue last year from underage people trying to get into bars and clubs.

Friday, immigrants' rights advocates wanted to know why those people weren't charged with ID theft like most illegal immigrants are.

"When underage students underage drinkers are using fake IDs to get drunk, the police department gives them a slap on the wrist, they tell them to never do it again and they send them on their way. When in fact someone who is trying to provide for their family is told that they have to remain in jail, given a class 4 felony," says Lydia Guzman.

"Why are they not being charged, because we give the kids presumption of the innocence, it's just a stupid thing? Do we know for sure, no but as a group as a class, we're just oh they're just kids being kids," says attorney David Cutrer.

Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery held a news conference of his own to address that allegation. He says the two issues are not the same.

"Fake ID's and buying alcohol - look, folks - it's not an identity theft offense," says Montgomery.

Montgomery says the way the state law is written, using a fake or altered ID is not considered the same violation as identity theft for the purpose of getting a job.

"And there is absolutely no basis for an argument that we're treating the ASU student on Mill Avenue who's 19 years old using a fake ID different than someone engaged in employment-related fraud, when Arizona law specifically prohibits treating the two the same."

Montgomery said the real difference here is that in many cases illegal immigrants are knowingly stealing someone's identity -- not just creating fake ones or altering a birth date.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Schumer proposes ban on 10 flame retardants

    Schumer proposes ban on 10 flame retardants

    Sunday, September 14 2014 9:51 PM EDT2014-09-15 01:51:05 GMT
    Gov. Andrew CuomoGov. Andrew Cuomo
    Senator Charles Schumer says a Duke University study has found flame retardants in upholstered furniture and children's products like toys, pajamas and pillows to be highly toxic. The chemicals have also been linked to developmental delays and rare cancers in firefighters as well as cancers and hormone disruption in children.
    Senator Charles Schumer says a Duke University study has found flame retardants in upholstered furniture and children's products like toys, pajamas and pillows to be highly toxic. The chemicals have also been linked to developmental delays and rare cancers in firefighters as well as cancers and hormone disruption in children.
  • Electricity goes out at Six Flags, guests left stranded

    Electricity goes out at Six Flags, guests left stranded

    Sunday, September 14 2014 6:50 PM EDT2014-09-14 22:50:36 GMT
    Six Flags Great Adventure 45th anniversary logo. (AP photo)Six Flags Great Adventure 45th anniversary logo. (AP photo)
    It wasn't the amusement park thrill they were expecting. Some people at Great Adventure in New Jersey were left stranded on rides after a power outage.
    It wasn't the amusement park thrill they were expecting. Some people at Great Adventure in New Jersey were left stranded on rides after a power outage.
  • Stranded jet skiers rescued off Staten Island

    Stranded jet skiers rescued off Staten Island

    Sunday, September 14 2014 6:43 PM EDT2014-09-14 22:43:09 GMT
    Two jet skiers stranded since Saturday night were rescued from small islands off of Staten Island Sunday morning, police sources said. The FDNY Marine division discovered the first jet skier on the West Bank Lighthouse island while patrolling the area after 8 a.m. Sunday, and took him to Staten Island University Hospital North. His friend, a man in his 40s, was also saved.
    Two jet skiers stranded since Saturday night were rescued from small islands off of Staten Island Sunday morning, police sources said. The FDNY Marine division discovered the first jet skier on the West Bank Lighthouse island while patrolling the area after 8 a.m. Sunday, and took him to Staten Island University Hospital North. His friend, a man in his 40s, was also saved.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices