Former St. Bonaventure Catholic Church Now Dangerous Eyesore - New York News | NYC Breaking News

Former St. Bonaventure Catholic Church Now Dangerous Eyesore

Posted: Updated:
Neighbors of the former St. Bonaventure Catholic church near 9th and Cambria say the building is becoming a dangerous eyesore. Neighbors of the former St. Bonaventure Catholic church near 9th and Cambria say the building is becoming a dangerous eyesore.
A shingle from the roof of the church is seen on the sidewalk. People who live in the area say the wind blows the shingles off of the roof. A shingle from the roof of the church is seen on the sidewalk. People who live in the area say the wind blows the shingles off of the roof.
NORTH PHILADELPHIA -

For a century, it was a religious centerpiece of Philadelphia's Fairhill neighborhood.

But now, the former St. Bonaventure Catholic church near 9th and Cambria is literally endangering lives.

Gaze skyward at the crumbling steeple of St. Bonaventure and you'll notice a family of Peregrine falcons.

But don't linger on the sidewalk below.

That's Ground Zero for the razor-sharp slate roofing shingles that fall from the spire when the winds blow.

Elizabeth Gutierrez lives just around the corner from the church, and remembers the late October night when Superstorm Sandy rumbled through the neighborhood.

"And my daughter sleeps in the back and the only thing she heard was, 'pop! pop! pop!' She said, 'mom, something's wrong!' (It was) slates coming down."

She says she called Philadelphia's Department of Licenses and Inspections to complain about the danger.

The city posted a sign, calling the structure "imminently dangerous," and ordering the owner- the New Life Evangelistic Church- to remove the steeple immediately.

That was November 3rd.

"So it says something there," says Gutierrez, as she peers at the sign with FOX 29s Bruce Gordon, "(but) there's nothing done."

St. Bonaventure was built in 1894, and served the community until dwindling attendance forced the Philadelphia Archdiocese to close its doors in 1993.

The city says New Life Evangelistic bought the place shortly thereafter, but the building has been vacant for years.

The women's halfway house right next door to St. Bonaventure has a bird's eye view of the damage done by scavengers.

The church has been stripped of copper, stained glass- anything of value.

And the lawn here is littered with fallen slate.

Rev. Mildred Kee surveys the mess and tells Gordon the church has been an eyesore for years

About two years ago, she says "the crack heads went in and ripped out all the water pipes, so the water came over in my building and I had a foot of water in my basement."

Gordon called Licenses and Inspections to report the neighbors' concerns.

A spokeswoman acknowledged the posted sign is misleading- that the city considers the church building "unsafe," but not yet "imminently dangerous."

Gordon's phone call to New Life was not returned by Thursday afternoon, but L & I got back to him and said his report had prompted them to re-inspected the structure.

L & I agreed, the building has deteriorated, and the city will now take the owner- New Life- to Equity court, where it can force repairs or demolition.

That's the good news.

The bad?

The legal process could take months to play out.

In the meantime, folks in the neighborhood around St. Bonaventure would be well advised to steer clear of the crumbling steeple.

"If that does come down," says Gutierrez, "somebody's going to die."

  • Send Email To FOX 29 News

    Have problems? Tell us.

    FOX 29 News is #GettingResults.

    * denotes required fields
    We're sorry, but only one entry is allowed per person.
    Thank you for your continued interest.

    Thanks for contacting FOX 29 News!

  • Getting Results

  • Monday, June 17 2013 6:46 PM EDT2013-06-17 22:46:46 GMT
    FOX 29, looking out for the safety of your kids with hot weather and swimming pool season soon to arrive.
    FOX 29, looking out for the safety of your kids with hot weather and swimming pool season soon to arrive.
  • Saturday, June 15 2013 9:56 AM EDT2013-06-15 13:56:15 GMT
    Her yard is ready for the pool that never came. Find out about the construction issue that has a homeowner turning to FOX 29 News to get results.
    Her yard is ready for the pool that never came. Find out about the construction issue that has a homeowner turning to FOX 29 News to get results.
  • Wednesday, June 12 2013 6:34 PM EDT2013-06-12 22:34:31 GMT
    The Trenton Titans minor league ice hockey team closed up shop back in April, for reasons that have never been fully explained. Now, season ticket holders have lost their team and their money.
    The Trenton Titans minor league ice hockey team closed up shop back in April, for reasons that have never been fully explained. Now, season ticket holders have lost their team and their money.
  • Bruce Gordon Reports

  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 6:07 PM EDT2013-06-18 22:07:39 GMT
    Published reports are saying this is a murder/suicide. The victim is 47 year old family practice doctor Michelle Liggio, and the alleged gunman is her estranged husband 58 year old Christopher.
    Published reports are saying this is a murder/suicide. The victim is 47 year old family practice doctor Michelle Liggio, and the alleged gunman is her estranged husband 58 year old Christopher.
  • Monday, June 17 2013 6:14 PM EDT2013-06-17 22:14:04 GMT
    Parents at a Port Richmond playground say they fear for their kids' safety. They feel intimidated by a street person living, nearly full time, in the park!
    Parents at a Port Richmond playground say they fear for their kids' safety. They feel intimidated by a street person living, nearly full time, in the park!
  • Wednesday, June 12 2013 6:34 PM EDT2013-06-12 22:34:31 GMT
    The Trenton Titans minor league ice hockey team closed up shop back in April, for reasons that have never been fully explained. Now, season ticket holders have lost their team and their money.
    The Trenton Titans minor league ice hockey team closed up shop back in April, for reasons that have never been fully explained. Now, season ticket holders have lost their team and their money.
  • Local News

  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 10:59 PM EDT2013-06-19 02:59:35 GMT
    At the annual American Medical Association (AMA) meeting in Chicago, doctors have voted to recognize obesity as an illness.
    At the annual American Medical Association (AMA) meeting in Chicago, doctors have voted to recognize obesity as an illness.
  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 10:43 PM EDT2013-06-19 02:43:10 GMT
    Times are tough for many in Philadelphia with almost half a million people turning to food pantries just to survive. Several organizations are working to provide healthy options.
    Times are tough for many in Philadelphia with almost half a million people turning to food pantries just to survive. Several organizations are working to provide healthy options.
  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 10:42 PM EDT2013-06-19 02:42:20 GMT
    The Rolling Stones take their "50 and Counting" tour to South Philly. They're touring the world to celebrate five decades together.
    The Rolling Stones take their "50 and Counting" tour to South Philly. They're touring the world to celebrate five decades together.
  • Local NewsLocal News

  • Service delays, cancellations

    Tuesday, June 18 2013 11:01 PM EDT2013-06-19 03:01:57 GMT
    Photo courtesy of @N42_21_W71_04)
    Riders should anticipate some changes but "near normal" service on the Long Island Rail Road for the Wednesday morning rush.

    Riders should anticipate some changes but "near normal" service on the Long Island Rail Road for the Wednesday morning rush. Crews have bee working to repair tracks and switches after Monday's derailment.

  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 9:50 PM EDT2013-06-19 01:50:52 GMT
    FDNY photo via Twitter
    Emergency responders rescued a worker who was trapped when a trench collapsed Tuesday evening at a Queens construction site that was supposed to be closed.
    Emergency responders rescued a worker who was trapped when a trench collapsed Tuesday evening at a Queens construction site that was supposed to be closed.
  • Tuesday, June 18 2013 8:34 PM EDT2013-06-19 00:34:07 GMT
    It's a sight that can trigger dread. The low-battery message appears on your cell phone when there's no charger around.
    It's a sight that can trigger dread. The low-battery message appears on your cell phone when there's no charger around. Now New York City has teamed up with AT&T to install 25 solar powered charging stations over the summer.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2013 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices