Aaron Schaffhausen enters plea of not guilty by insanity - New York News

Schaffhausen enters plea of not guilty by insanity in River Falls murders

Posted: Updated:
HUDSON, Wis. (KMSP) -

Aaron Schaffhausen, the father of three girls found slain in their mother's home, has officially entered a plea of not guilty by reason if mental disease and defect to all four counts he faces in the deaths.

On Wednesday, the plea was filed in St. Croix County -- 33 days after the court issued a deadline for an insanity plea.

Schaffhausen has been charged with three counts of first-degree intentional homicide and one count of attempted arson in the deaths of his daughters.

The 35-year-old from Minot, ND, is accused of killing 5-year-old Cecilia, 8-year-old Sophie and 11-year-old Amara Schaffhausen during a visit in July.

The judge had set a Dec. 14 deadline for an insanity plea earlier, saying a flexible plea timeframe could complicate the case.

A hearing is set for Thursday. For now, court clerks say the trial is still set to begin on April 1; however, the plea could push back the trial date -- and the trial itself could last longer with all the testimony an insanity plea will bring.

So far, Schaffhausen has sat silent in every hearing. He hasn't uttered a word or displayed an emotion, but the brief, one-page brief filed in court speaks volumes.

"The only option Mr. Schaffhausen would have would be to claim insanity," said criminal defense attorney Joe Tamburino, who said he's not surprised at all by the plea.

Tamburino is licensed in both Minnesota and Wisconsin, and he told FOX 9 News there is a big difference between the two states when it comes to an insanity plea.

"In Wisconsin, they have what's called 'substantial capacity defense,'" he explained. "He would have to not be able to understand the nature of his acts. It's a little bit easier of a burden to show than in Minnesota. In Minnesota, you basically have to not understand anything -- you just don't know what you are doing."

If the experts have not yet examined Schaffhausen yet, Tamburino says the trial date could be pushed back. When it begins, he says it won't be a quick process.

Tamburino explained that there will be two parts. The first will focus on determining if Schaffhausen killed his three children. If so, the second phase -- which could last three to four weeks -- will focus on determining whether he can be held legally responsible.

"When you bring up the issue of mental illness, you are going to involve a whole slew of different witnesses. There are going to be expert witnesses, psychologists. So much is going to be concentrated on: What's this person's mental state? Their history? Their testing? Their interviews?" Tamburino said. "It's going to open up a whole new can of worms."

As for how successful the strategy may be, Tamburino said he thinks it will still be "difficult."

"In a case like this, Schaffhausen -- according to the complaint -- was making calls to the home, talking to the ex-wife. Hours went by by the time he got to the home where the kids were," he said.

No matter what the jury ultimately decides, Schaffhausen won't be free any time soon. A guilty verdict would likely keep him in prison for the rest of his life. If he's found not guilty, he'll be referred to a mental facility where he could eventually be released; however, Tamburino believes that is not very likely.


  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • 2 upper level GWB east lanes closed for repairs

    2 upper level GWB east lanes closed for repairs

    Tuesday, July 22 2014 1:19 PM EDT2014-07-22 17:19:59 GMT
    Workers have closed two upper level eastbound lanes on the George Washington Bridge for emergency repairs. The closures affect New York City bound motorists. Officials expect the lanes will remain closed until 3 p.m. Tuesday. Motorists heading into New York City should use the lower level or consider alternate Hudson River crossings.
    Workers have closed two upper level eastbound lanes on the George Washington Bridge for emergency repairs. The closures affect New York City bound motorists. Officials expect the lanes will remain closed until 3 p.m. Tuesday. Motorists heading into New York City should use the lower level or consider alternate Hudson River crossings.
  • FAA bans all flights to Tel Aviv airport

    FAA bans all flights to Tel Aviv airport

    Tuesday, July 22 2014 12:59 PM EDT2014-07-22 16:59:29 GMT
    The Federal Aviation Administration has banned U.S. carriers from flying to Israel's main airport for 24 hours. The FAA made the announcement at about 12:40 p.m. on Tuesday. This comes after two U.S. airlines cancelled all flights to Israel until further notice following a rocket landing near the Ben-Gurion Airport earlier in the day.
    The Federal Aviation Administration has banned U.S. carriers from flying to Israel's main airport for 24 hours. The FAA made the announcement at about 12:40 p.m. on Tuesday. This comes after two U.S. airlines cancelled all flights to Israel until further notice following a rocket landing near the Ben-Gurion Airport earlier in the day.
  • White flags raised at Brooklyn Bridge

    White flags raised at Brooklyn Bridge

    Tuesday, July 22 2014 12:52 PM EDT2014-07-22 16:52:11 GMT
    Police responded to the Brooklyn Bridge on Tuesday for a major security breach at one of the most highly secured landmarks in New York City. Two white flags — international symbols of surrender — fluttered from poles on the stone supports that hold cables above the span connecting Brooklyn and Manhattan. It is not clear who raised the flags that had a faint appearance of the stars and stripes or why.  The American flags that are normally up at the bridge were removed.
    Police responded to the Brooklyn Bridge on Tuesday for a major security breach at one of the most highly secured landmarks in New York City. Two white flags — international symbols of surrender — fluttered from poles on the stone supports that hold cables above the span connecting Brooklyn and Manhattan. It is not clear who raised the flags that had a faint appearance of the stars and stripes or why.  The American flags that are normally up at the bridge were removed.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices