Grand jury investigating Justice Hathaway's property dealings - New York News | NYC Breaking News

Grand jury investigating Justice Hathaway's property dealings

Posted: Updated:

By Charlie LeDuff
Fox 2 News Reporter


GROSSE POINTE PARK, Mich. (WJBK) -- As if the feds weren't already hanging more paper than an interior decorator on suspect government officials out of Wayne County, Fox 2 has confirmed yet another grand jury investigation.

This time it's Michigan Supreme Court Justice Diane Hathaway, who told her bank she was too poor to live in tony Grosse Pointe Park, and the bank agreed.

So what's she doing living in tony Grosse Pointe Park?

This is a tale of four houses.  Let's begin with the one of Lakeview where she lived with her husband, a successful slip and fall lawyer.  They said they couldn't afford the $1.5 million mortgage and had to move out, so the bank allowed them to sell the home for about half of what they owed on it.  That's called a short sale.

"You have to demonstrate a hardship, something that's changed in your life that no longer allows you to meet your obligations on a mortgage loan.  What we see most commonly is a change in employment status, a change in marital status or some sort of health concerns," said real estate lawyer T. Scott Galloway.

But what hardship?  She's got a job, he's got a job, and they own two other houses.  The feds think this whole deal might be garbage.

Before she was approved for the short sale, she gave away one of her homes to her stepdaughter, a swanky pad in Florida with a boat dock worth three quarters of a million dollars.  A house that they owned outright.

She also gave a home to her stepson just a stone's throw away from the short sale house.  She paid $170,000 cash for it in 2010.

Last November, the short sale went through and Hathaway sold her $1.5 million mortgage to a guy for $850,000.

So Hathaway is homeless, right?  Wrong.  Yet another stepdaughter bought a house in Grosse Pointe Park for $200,000 just months before the short sale, and just a few months after the short sale that stepdaughter signed it over to the judge.  Then the other stepdaughter after the short sale went through signed the Florida house back over to the judge.

One more thing.  According to documents obtained by Fox News, the feds are looking at a possible tax fraud because when Hathaway owned the home that she gave to her stepson and the short sale house, tax breaks were claimed on both when you're only entitled to claim it on one.

Justice Hathaway wouldn't answer our questions.

  • Charlie LeDuffCharlie LeDuff

  • Off the Chain Editorial

    Friday, May 17 2013 5:25 PM EDT2013-05-17 21:25:50 GMT
    Following Minister Louis Farrakhan's message on Friday, Fox 2's Charlie LeDuff hit the streets to scrounge around for some available investment properties, and guess what he found?
    Following Minister Louis Farrakhan's message on Friday, Fox 2's Charlie LeDuff hit the streets to scrounge around for some available investment properties, and guess what he found?
  • Thursday, May 16 2013 7:45 PM EDT2013-05-16 23:45:45 GMT
    Fox 2's Charlie LeDuff attended a Detroit City Council meeting.  On the agenda, some questions about a developer who is being allowed to take his time paying back a $19-million dollar loan.
    On Thursday, Fox 2's Charlie LeDuff attended a Detroit City Council meeting.  On the meeting agenda, some questions about a developer with connections to city hall who received a letter that told him he was allowed to take his time paying back a $19-million dollar loan.
  • Wednesday, May 15 2013 11:16 PM EDT2013-05-16 03:16:04 GMT
    Dave Bing might run for Wayne County executive, but a condition is the officer holder must be a county resident. Charlie LeDuff decides to help his old buddy out with a few options on where he can live.
    Dave Bing might run for Wayne County executive, but a condition is the officer holder must be a county resident. Charlie LeDuff decides to help his old buddy out with a few options on where he can live.
  • Local NewsLocal News

  • Monday, May 20 2013 10:42 PM EDT2013-05-21 02:42:18 GMT
    Omar Morales feels lucky to be here for his son Joshua's 10th birthday on Monday. Morales was one of the passengers on board a USAir flight that made an emergency landing at Newark Liberty.
    Omar Morales feels lucky to be here for his son Joshua's 10th birthday on Monday. Morales was one of the passengers on board a USAir flight that made an emergency landing at Newark Liberty.
  • Superstorm Sandy

    Monday, May 20 2013 10:32 PM EDT2013-05-21 02:32:00 GMT
    Sue Ellen Turner, a Lavallette, N.J., lifer, loves documenting her ever-changing life on the beach through pictures.
    Sue Ellen Turner, a Lavallette, N.J., lifer, loves documenting her ever-changing life on the beach through pictures.
  • Monday, May 20 2013 10:28 PM EDT2013-05-21 02:28:23 GMT
    After Assemblyman Vito Lopez resigned over claims of serial sexual harassment of female staffers, attention turned to whether powerful Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver should continue his leadership.
    After Assemblyman Vito Lopez resigned over claims of serial sexual harassment of female staffers, attention turned to whether powerful Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver should continue his leadership.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2013 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices