Miranda Rights at the Center of Debra Milke Appeal - New York News

Miranda Rights at the Center of Debra Milke Appeal

Posted:

Debra Milke has been on death row for 20 years, convicted of having her son killed for a share of an insurance policy. But now she could get a new trial -- and it's all because of questions surrounding her alleged confession.

A Phoenix detective says she confessed to the whole sordid crime, but did he violate her Miranda rights? The interrogation was never recorded, and Milke never signed a waiver giving up her right to remain silent.

Last year, a federal appeals court in California found there was no evidence Milke waived her Miranda rights. Now a federal judge in Phoenix is taking a fresh look.

4-year-old Christopher Milke was taken into the desert by two men and shot three times in December 1989. Milke's live-in boyfriend, James Lynn Styers, and his friend Roger Mark Scott, were also convicted in the plot.

In court Monday, Milke told a federal judge that Detective Armando Saldate badgered her during the murder interrogation. And even after she asked for a lawyer, she says he wouldn't stop asking questions.

An attorney who wrote a friend-of-the-court brief for Milke's attorney says it's outrageous the interrogation was never taped.

"I think most civilized people now understand it is inexcusable for law enforcement deliberately to make a decision not to record an interrogation in any homicide case or serious felony," says attorney Larry Hammond.

Under friendly questioning by the Arizona Attorney General's office, former detective Armando Saldate testified that Milke knew exactly what was going on during questioning, and that she confessed.

Milke's attorneys portrayed Saldate as a fame-hungry cop who repeatedly ignored Miranda warnings, questioning suspects in a number of cases even after they asked for a lawyer and the right to remain silent.

Saldate says he asked Debra Milke if she wanted the interrogation taped, and she said no. But her attorneys disagree.

If the federal judge decides that Milke's confession violated the law, he could throw it out and order a new trial. The hearing continues on Tuesday.
 

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    Friday, August 29 2014 8:47 AM EDT2014-08-29 12:47:22 GMT
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
  • Security stepped up for Electric Zoo Festival

    Security stepped up for Electric Zoo Festival

    Friday, August 29 2014 8:34 AM EDT2014-08-29 12:34:04 GMT
    Festival goers to one of the most popular events of the summer in New York City will see major changes this weekend.  The Electric Zoo festival featuring headliner David Guetta takes place Saturday and Sunday on Randall's Island. Organizers are expecting 45,000 people, daily. Last year's party was cut short after the deaths of  Olivia Rotundo, 20, of Providence, R.I. and Jeffrey Russ, 23, of Rochester, N.Y. 
    Festival goers to one of the most popular events of the summer in New York City will see major changes this weekend.  The Electric Zoo festival featuring headliner David Guetta takes place Saturday and Sunday on Randall's Island. Organizers are expecting 45,000 people, daily. Last year's party was cut short after the deaths of  Olivia Rotundo, 20, of Providence, R.I. and Jeffrey Russ, 23, of Rochester, N.Y. 
  • Joan Rivers remains in NYC hospital

    Joan Rivers remains in NYC hospital

    Friday, August 29 2014 7:54 AM EDT2014-08-29 11:54:57 GMT
    Hollywood legend Joan Rivers, 81, remains in critical but stable condition at The Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan. The comedian and TV host was undergoing an outpatient procedure at a clinic on the Upper East Side on Thursday when she went into cardiac arrest and was rushed to the hospital. Her daughter, Melissa Rivers, issued a statement saying her mother was "resting comfortably."

    Hollywood legend Joan Rivers, 81, remains in critical but stable condition at The Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan. The comedian and TV host was undergoing an outpatient procedure at a clinic on the Upper East Side on Thursday when she went into cardiac arrest and was rushed to the hospital. Her daughter, Melissa Rivers, issued a statement saying her mother was "resting comfortably."

Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices