Debate Over ID Cards for Illegal Immigrants

MYFOXNY.COM - Many cities around the country are so-called sanctuary cities for undocumented residents. Police and other public employees are banned from asking people whether they are in the country legally.

Some places, including New Haven, Conn., take it one step further and issue identification cards to any resident who asks for one -- regardless of immigration status.

New Haven officials say the cards have many uses, including providing access to libraries, parks, discounts to certain stores, and help the bearer open a bank account.

Proponents say the cards are crime fighters, giving illegal immigrants the courage to come forward with information about crime because they are guaranteed protection from deportation.

But critics say illegal immigrants are cheating taxpayers and the cards can lead to fraud.

All sides want a clear federal immigration program to lessen tensions and, in some cases, violence.

New Haven began issuing the cards in 2007. The cards are valid only within the city. Neither the state nor the federal government recognizes them.

Meantime, three municipalities in New Jersey issue similar cards: Trenton, Princeton, and Asbury Park. In those cases, local groups issue the cards, which are endorsed by town agencies and local law enforcement.